Reviews of Billy's Bakery (Bakery)

1 W 59th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

Average Rating:


We offer you all the opinions of people who consume the services of Billy\'s Bakery (Bakery) in the area close to the state of New York.

At the moment this firm has a score of 3.7 over 5 and this score has been based on 29 reviews.

You may have noticed that its rating is high, and it's based on a large number of opinions, so we can conclude that the rating is very credible. If there are many people who bothered to give their review when they are satisfied with the service, it works.

You know that we don't usually bother to set evaluations when they are positive and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or issue...

This Bakery corresponds to the category of Bakery.

Where is Billy's Bakery?

REVIEWS OF Billy's Bakery IN New York

Arturo Torres Castro

Disappointing red velvet. Around 5PM this afternoon I bought a slice of red velvet cake ($7.95). I can say it was no more than disappointing. The cake itself was dry, way too crumbly and lacked the chocolaty factor. (Maybe it was not fresh?) I honestly thought this cake would taste, as the brand says “home made”, sadly it was not the case. I will give 2 stars instead of 1 because te personnel was very kind. I hope Billy’s Bakery implements changes in their product or supply chain as they can do much better. Hopefully those modifications will be made soon enough and we will all be able to enjoy good slice of home made red velvet cake in their establishment.

roberto galli

František Pešek

Max R

CSanchez Films

Had a great time enjoyed the red velvet cupcake. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Robyn Suna

Was super hungry and found the food hall at The Plaza. I love cupcakes so bought one for a quick sugar high. Was paying for the cupcake and saw a cellophane pkg of oatmeal raisin cookies. Asked the salesclerk if they were good. her reply "those are really good" with the emphasis on "those". And the cookies were very good. The cupcake, however, was really bad. Tasted like it was not just one day but 2 days old. Dry and stale. I threw it away after one bite. I would recommend the cookies though.

Morgan Kaschak

Billy Cat

I loved it there the red velvet cupcakes are my favorite

Niyah Channel

Debra Minuto

Got a chocolate cupcake as stale as can be

Ben van Rooy

Great cakes

Mark Christopher

Horrible experience everytime I get the African American girl who has a bad attitude. I work nearby and like to bring a few cupcakes home sometimes . I dont like to write negative reviews to a place I like but tonight now she leaves me no choice . She tells me she will charge me for a box when I ask for one, . She throws the cupcake in a bag and messes it all up due to her . I will not buy from there no more when I notice her working . Neither will any of my employees. (many)

christina ma

(Translated by Google) This is one of the few places I have to go every time I'm in one of Manhattan. High-quality high-grade food, really let me into vacation mode, first-class service, no embarrassment, if you go to a person (because it is not a formal sit down restaurant). If you only have one meal there, I recommend: Luke's lobster roll (or, if you are really hungry, their sampling), the American one from Stumptown coffee, green tea cake from Mrs. M crepe complete again from the Epicerie Boulud the restaurant bought some white beard and honey nut or cherry yogurt to take home (one of the best yogurt I was in New York, locally made) here for a second meal, try Viva crepe or pasta bar. By the Fulangsuowa of Payard pastry dessert followed. Skip thing: from the pasta bar, William Gelinboge black and white cookies, from Asian noodle place next to La Maison du Chocolat Macaron Ramen Tip: go outside lunch hours, breaks out of that time limit even on weekdays. Free WIFI does not work so well. (Original) 這是為數不多的地方,我必須去每次我在曼哈頓就是之一。高品質的高檔食品,真正讓我進入假期模式,一流的服務,沒有尷尬,如果你一個人去(因為它不是一個坐下來正式的餐廳)。如果你只能有1那裡吃飯,我建議:盧克的龍蝦輥(或者,如果你是真的餓了他們的採樣),美式一個來自Stumptown咖啡,從M夫人綠茶蛋糕縐完成再從Epicerie的Boulud餐廳買了一些白鬍子蜂蜜和螺母或櫻桃酸奶帶回家(之一最好的酸奶我曾經在紐約當地製造)這裡進行了第二餐,嘗試萬歲縐或麵食吧。由弗朗索瓦的Payard糕點點心緊隨其後。事情跳過:從麵食吧,威廉·格林伯格的黑色和白色的餅乾,從梅森巧克力馬卡龍旁邊的亞洲麵條的地方拉麵提示:去的午餐時間以外,休息十分限時連平日那個時代。免費的WIFI不工作那麼好。

Robby Hecker

Found a hair in my pudding.

Des R

Uws doesn’t have a big selection. What’s the point? Offer everything or nothing!

Jennie Nutt

Best service ever. The Gentleman couldn't be more friendlier and observant to the customer if he tried. Way better than Olma'svacross the walkway who were so, so rude to an international customer and I will spread the word back to Australia how grwat Billy's s errvice was and Olma's was NOT.

Ayaka Nishihata

Artemis Diaz

The best carrot cupcakes in the universe, super creamy, no too sweet. Mmm!

Raul Avila

Baked cakes, pies and pudding

Magnus Fox

I like the German chocolate cupcakes

Francesco Aveta

Per chi la vuole provare la prima e vera Red Velvet è qui!

Janet Ruggiero

Teresa Towne

I came to visit my friend Kessi Who decorated a beautiful guava cake for my daughters ages 13th birthday we also tried a few of their delicious donuts and really enjoyed that they had lots of seating area so you can enjoy it fresh... Also my daughter Alli enjoyed that they had Wi-Fi there!


Avoid this place, they're able to hike up prices due to location. They were out of a cake that I wanted and so I chose the lemon raspberry cake that the workers recommended. I paid $60 for a cake that is normally priced at $40. I brought this cake for my father's birthday and EVERYONE was so disappointed they would rather have a Baskin Robin cake. It was really disappointing and disgusting. Would have been happily ripped off, if the cake actually tasted good. Go to Lady M instead.

Gerardo Hernandez

I recently discovered this underground gem, I was delighted to try out their blueberry cheesecake. It was recommended to me by one of the employees and honestly it is the best thing I’ve ever tasted in my 29 years of eating cheesecake. I washed it down with one of their lattes and it just made the experience so much better. If you ever come to The Plaza Food Hall I highly recommend over any of the other bakery’s there.

Md Olil

Laura Grubb

Greet place to get coffee and pastry in morning before heading out to shop on 5th Avenue. Lattes are great.

Ahmad Dhahi

I am usually not that kind of a person, but I stood there for 10 minutes being ignored by the sales girl. Tried to put my hand out for her to see me, called her and literally stood in front of her with no response. Funny thing is that she was selling for anyone else made an iced coffee for another client but still ignored me when I was the only person with no one around me to buy. Wish I tried the carrot cake with cream cheese.

Rhian Bull

We ordered a red velvet cake, for collection to celebrate our vow renewal. The staff we friendly, and the cake was wonderful and perfect.

Business Hours of Billy's Bakery in New York



Billy's Bakery en New York
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Katz's Delicatessen
Katz's Delicatessen
Bakery - New York

Traditional American restaurant

Abu's Homestyle Bakery
Abu's Homestyle Bakery
Bakery - New York


Bakery - New York


Villabate Alba
Villabate Alba
Bakery - New York

Dessert shop

Clementine Bakery
Clementine Bakery
Bakery - New York