Reviews of The Vintage Cake (Bakery)

171 1st Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, United States

Average Rating:


We have the opinions of people like you who bought the products and services of The Vintage Cake (Bakery) in the state of New Jersey.

At the moment this business receives a rating of 5.0 out of 5 and the rating is based on 44 reviews.

As you can read, its rating is outstanding, indeed, it gets the best punctuation it can earn., and it is based on a very large number of reviews, so we can conclude that the assessment is very faithful. If many people have bothered to leave their opinion when they are satisfied, is that it works.

As you know, we do not usually bother to place reviews when these are good and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Wedding bakery.

Where is The Vintage Cake?

REVIEWS OF The Vintage Cake IN New Jersey

sherri B

I ordered my dad's birthday cake from vintage and I had no idea what to get. I sent over an image of the party theme and they produced a BEAUTIFUL CAKE that was a perfect match. It also tasted absolutely AMAZING! It was a big hit at the party and we will be ordering with vintage for all future events. They have excellent customer service, GREAT communication and their cake is delicious. It was an absolute pleasure working with them :)


So easy picking delicious flavors and they helped bring my vision and idea to life!

Suzanne Petrini

The Vintage Cake is amazing! I have ordered two cakes for two different occasions and both were gorgeous and delicious - it's hard to come across that perfect combination! I have a couple of more orders in the making and plan to use them for future occasions as well.

Shannon Collier

The Vintage Cake is the perfect place to go if you are Gluten-Free! They went above and beyond to accommodate my needs and created the most delicious cake for my birthday. They really took their time to answer all my allergy questions and if they didn't know the answer, they went and found out for me. They were very knowledgable and accommodating to my gluten allergy. I wasn't worried about cross contamination. I've also ordered their Apple Strudel, and it was one of the best Gluten-Free Apple Strudel's I have ever had! And what can I say about their French Macarons! The Vintage Cake is my go to spot for French Macarons. They are simple the best French Macarons in New Jersey. The Vintage Cake will not disappoint! Easily one of the best places around!

Scott Broschart

Their peanut butter mousse is heavenly.

Amanda Chisholm

The Vintage Cake was so easy to work with and very accommodating. There desserts were not only beautiful but so delicious! They are fabulous.

Jenny Horowitz

Elegant, delicious and perfect for any occasion. If you're looking to impress your guests with a cake that looks amazing and tastes incredible, this is the place.

Marie Ferrante

Amazing service, beautiful and delicious cakes. Their macarons are the best around. I highly recommend!

Andrew Leone

Gina runs her business like a true professional with the friendliness of someone I've known for years. She has a real eye for detail and the scientific genius to make heavenly cakes and fillings. Her work looks, tastes, and smells as amazing as she is. I would recommend her to anyone looking to make the cake a star of the show.

Jake Bowers

Gina and The Vintage Cake were awesome from start to finish!! The cake made my wife’s special day even more amazing with a truly stunning and delicious 2 tier cake for her baby shower! Look no further than these amazing ladies and their superb talent if you are trying to find the perfect cake!!

Kiamarie Stone

I ordered 3 cakes for my engagement party & they were delivered exactly as I had explained & hoped they would be & extremely delicious! My guests were in awe over the pretty detail of them!

Susanna Lee

The Vintage Cake is so creative! Who else could make a wedding cake that looks just like Yankee Stadium, to celebrate the couple's favorite team? They will make you the cake of your dreams!

Jordan Albright

Put simply... the best cake I've ever had.

Ashley Taylor

If you're looking for an artist to delight your tastebuds, then look no further. If you want to work with someone down to earth, kind, and've struck gold. There is no one I'd rather have make a special creation for a special day!

Nicole C

Hands down, best macaroons I have ever had!

Anisha Patel

Have ordered from The Vintage Cake a few times and their cakes never disappoint! Easy to work with and accommodating, they also accept Venmo.

Jillian MacFarlane

Laura Chamoun

It’s very hard to find a place with amazing customer service and quality anymore. This Place is 100% in every way. Will definitely return for all my cake needs!!!

Jessica Alevras

You can't go wrong with The Vintage Cake! Not only do Gina and Nancy provide beautiful, elegant and delicious cakes, but they are an absolute delight to work with. From my initial conversation to the delivery of my cake and macaroons, everything was top notch! I did not have to worry if my calls would be returned, if my order was going to be as we discussed or if my delivery would go smoothly; I felt taken care of. I can't stress enough how important that is to have in a vendor. You will not go wrong with The Vintage Cake....Thank you Gina and Nancy!

Christopher Arnold

Great cake and great people! Couldn't be happier with our order and Gina was a pleasure to work with!

Kaitlin Wright

The Vintage Cake prepares utterly exquisite works of edible art- not only is each confectionary delight absolutely beautiful to behold, they taste even better than they look (which is hard to believe, until you have sampled these delicacies). Everything is made from scratch, by hand, using only the highest quality ingredients, by dedicated & experienced professional artisans. I have had the distinct pleasure of trying a wide array of the delights offered by The Vintage Cake, and each one is a culinary masterpiece. Each offering is absolutely delicious- from the macarons, to the petit fours (my personal favorite!) to the dizzying array of cake options- Gina and Nancy are truly masters of their craft. Gina and Nancy created an absolutely stunning two tiered cake for my engagement party last spring. It was, hands down, the most delicious, balanced, moist, LOVELY cake I have ever had the pleasure of tasting. My only regret is that my fiance & I each only had a few bites of that heavenly cake- we got swept up in the party and by the time we were ready to have second helpings, it had been devoured! I cannot recommend this business enough!

Stephanie Richter

The Vintage Cake is our "go-to" spot for delicious and beautiful desserts. From their cakes and cupcakes to their macarons, you can't go wrong. Gina is so professional and works with you to make your vision of your event perfect.

Steve Taylor

cake was amazing! Texture was on point and looked good. Will definitely be ordering again!

Subadra Murugan


Another PHENOMENAL cake by these ladies!

Steph Kurilla

When I am bored or hungry I look at all of Gina's beautiful creations from Vintage Cake and remember how awesome they were to eat! Gina is absolutely the best. You can see and taste all the love she pours into her recipes and designs.

Melanie Brown

The girls from The Vintage Cake did a phenomenal job with my son's bar mitzvah cake. Everyone raved about the perfect taste and looks. They were so professional too!

Scott Alevras

I cant say enough good things about The Vintage Cake. Excellent work, reasonable prices and consummate professionals running the show. Thank you Nancy and Gina for making my event extra special!

Natalia Gural

Amazing work. I ordered a cake for my boyfriend's birthday with a motorcycle and two little people on it (myself and him) and they made it look very neat. The sculpturing was very clean and the red velvet cake tasted good. I was very afraid to order cakes, it was my first time but this bakery did not dissapoint and all the guests were amazed. Also, will have to mention that this bakery gave me a decent price compared to other bakeries. Will definitely go back now.

Chris O

There aren't enough good things that I can say about Vintage Cakes! Simply outstanding. Period. The design they came up for our cake was exquisite, and that's not a word I use lightly. And the taste... delicious! Honestly, one of the best cakes I've had in years! Let's put it this way... now that I've had a cake from The Vintage Cake, I wouldn't trust anyone else with my cake desires.

Todd Broschart

Everything I have had from the Vintage Cake has been fantastic. Amazing cake with raspberry butter cream, wonderful melt in your mouth cookies and the macarons are killer. Everything is top notch and delicious. I highly recommend them.

Stephanie Hulse

These cakes are amazing! I follow them on Instagram and I'm constantly amazed at what they can do. Highly recommend!!

Alan Moretti

Best cakes for birthday parties on the Jersey Shore.

yvonne semente

Daria Koprowska

From tasting to final product everything was excellent. My daughters baptism cake was so beautiful and absolutely delicious. I got so many compliments on her cake. I will definitely be ordering again soon for her first birthday.

Deena El-Attar

Exceptional service start to finish. Extreme attention to detail starting with the tasting and design stage until completion and delivery. I highly recommend the Vintage Cake for your next occasion!

Laura Trama

I ordered my dream cake for my birthday from The Vintage Cake, vanilla buttercream(extra on the buttercream), vanilla cake, covered in non nonpareil sprinkles. It was moist and the buttercream made from real butter not crisco, so delicious and can't wait to order a cake from there again. They were so accommodating and even delivered the cake to my house. I give The Vintage Cake 5 stars because the exceeded my expectations. Thanks Gina and your team!

Marc Richter

The Vintage Cake is simply outstanding! Not only are their cakes a work of art, but they are delicious, too. We use them for all our occasions including birthdays. Couldn't be happier, which is why we keep returning.

Sahnaz Saleem

We used The Vintage Cake for both of our wedding events (the ceremony and the wedding reception). We can't even begin to explain how much we loved both of our cakes. Our cakes were not only beautiful, but they were extremely delicious. Many of our guests said that it was the best cake they've ever had. Their pricing is expensive at first glance, but for the product that they deliver and their extreme care and attention to detail really makes it all worth it. They also are very good at working with you if you have a budget. They are good at giving budget-friendly options while not compromising the look or taste of their product. We will DEFINITELY be using them in the future. Thanks again for two amazing cakes!

Varsha Ahir

We are extremely happy to have chosen The Vintage Cake for our wedding. Nancy's happy and warm personality made us very comfortable in discussing our ideas. She promptly replied to all our queries with her expert inputs which makes her reliable in every sense. Our wedding cake looked so beautiful, it came out just the way we had envisioned it. It was delicious, rich and everything a cake should be.

Vanessa Tapia

The best I've ever experienced!

Colby Michelle

The Vintage Cake has made cakes for several very important life events for our family. Not only are the cakes BEAUTIFUL, but they are also EXTREMELY delicious!

Sean Collier

You will forever compare all macaroons to the macaroons from the Vintage Cake.

Business Hours of The Vintage Cake in New Jersey



The Vintage Cake en New Jersey
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Las Américas Bakery
Las Américas Bakery
Bakery - New Jersey


Eet Gud Bakery
Eet Gud Bakery
Bakery - New Jersey


Magnolia Bakery
Magnolia Bakery
Bakery - New Jersey


A Little Cake
A Little Cake
Bakery - New Jersey


Balthazar Bakery
Balthazar Bakery
Bakery - New Jersey