Reviews of Mueller's Bakery (Bakery)

80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head, NJ 08742, United States

Average Rating:


We've got all the information of people like you who used the services of Mueller\'s Bakery (Bakery) in the area close to New Jersey.

Now this firm gets a score of 4.7 stars out of 5 and that rating is based on 464 reviews.

As you can read, it reaches an reviews average is nearly the best one, and it's based on a very large number of scores, so we can be quite sure that the assessment is quite faithful. If people have bothered to rate when they've done well with the service, it works.

As you know, we do not usually bother to set tatings when these are correct and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Bakery.

Where is Mueller's Bakery?

REVIEWS OF Mueller's Bakery IN New Jersey

Tara Greene

EXCELLENT pastries. They made my wedding cake and they were prompt and very professional.

Jim McLaughlin

Great service and many terrific treats. Enjoyed a delicious, fresh blueberry fritter this morning. It was excellent!

Joe Skelly

This is the best bakery at the Jersey Shore. Nuff said.

cindie schue

Awesome place. Great baked good and a great staff

Karen Mattice

EVERYTHING is so delicious! I want to eat it all, but my wardrobe won't allow it!

Paul Kennedy

Whenever we're in Bay Head, we have to stop at Mueller's. The best crumb cake anywhere!

Andrew Albanese

Went on a Saturday night about 4:30 in the afternoon with a line out the door waited about 15 minutes but it was worth the wait if you go you must try the crumb cake

Griz Bear

Everything and anything from here is delicious. Blueberry Pudding Cake and the Crumb Cakes are awesome. Be prepared to wait in line on the weekends.

Simona Dimeo

Ordered a cake and it was the worst i have ever seen. I could have decorated a better cake and im not even a cake designer. Do yourself a favor and don’t upset yourself day of event by ordering a cake through Mullers Bakery.

joni Brennan

Everything is delicious but the cannon cake is to die for!

Jean Marie Howard

Best bakery in New Jersey!

Joe Laurenzano

Tons of options (with a line out the door to show you how many people love this place). Of course the main attraction is their crumb buns. Put them in your bucket list, seriously.

Aidan Garrett

Best coffee cakes i ever had

Marvin Bigeleisen

Can't beat this place I come here from Florida to visit and Muller's is must stop ..

Jennifer Pellosie

Best crumb cake and donuts you'll find in Ocean County

Craig A. Smith

A must visit. Just take a number.

Dave Sheldon

Go there during OFF Peak hours. Try the Chocolate butter cookies.

karen romano

Unbelievable baked goods but a little pricey. Go for won't be sorry!!!

Amanda Zega

The crumb cake was amazing! Tried brownies, cookies, and pastries... brownies without nuts were amazing!!

Mary Ann Belliveau

Always excellent. Worth the wait!

Bonnie Delaney

Best crumb cake, blueberry rings, giant cookies, and awesomely decorated cupcakes.

Paul s

Best bakery

Michael Todd

The best. From the crumb cake to the tea biscuits. My fiancé bought carrot cupcakes for my 40th and were the best I’ve ever had. If you visit during the summer months be prepared to arrive early, grab a great cup of coffee and wait.

Joe Scott

Outstanding products, you'll get huge if you eat here alot.

tony baloney

Nothing but delicious

Thomas Cedrone

Always the best of everything. The glazed crumb cake is amazing. Been coming here for decades and it never disappoints. Great service from an always friendly staff.

Louise Travaglio

Muellers bakery is the BEST! We love their crumb buns, breads, jelly donuts and wonderful cookies! We just moved back from Florida where we really missed our favorite bakery Mueller’s.

Rose Marie Parsell

Best bakery in town. Everything you can imagine is there and all delicious.

Cheryl Dippel

Best bakery around. I love the coffee cakes.

Mike Kizis

One of the best bakeries ever! Insanely delicious blueberry cheese rafts, and their signature crumb buns.

heart attack on a plate

Great pastries great bakery

Vincent Mastria

Best Crumb Cake ever!

cheryl monaco

Products are always fresh and delicious

Ken And Kim Tronsberg

A Bay Head treasure! What a great place to go early in the morning for some of the Jersey Shore's best baked goods. The Crumb Cake? Oh my, I cannot get their early enough. My family gets to the shore about 6 times a year between April and October, and every time we arrive the first thing on the agenda is who will be getting up early to go to Mueller's for Crumb Cake. That aside they also have beautiful cakes for all occasions..great donuts and fresh breads. I could go on for hours. If you have been there, you know. If this is your first time there, go early! We will be seeing you soon!

michael fiore

Old Fashion Bakery, Great selection of bake goods from bread to pies. Could improve on making coffee, real off turn when coffee is cold. $$$

Terri Biringer

Best bakery in Ocean County! Try the Irish soda bread if it's available. All of the baked goods are excellent!!!

Connor Sheridan

Legendary local bakery I've been going to all my life. Crumb cake is amazing and so is everything else. Also stop in for a cup of coffee and walk around beautiful Bayhead!

Bill Schrader

Can't resist crumb buns


Overrated coffee cake

Ingrid Seduikis

One of the best if not the best! Don't expect everything to be great but for my taste buds 50 % of baked goods are much better than anywhere else.

Melanie Caruso

Muellers has been my favorite bakery since childhood! You won’t find a better Sesame Street cupcake, crumb bun or special cake anywhere else! They recently catered my engagement party, rehearsal dinner and wedding! Literally couldn’t have asked for anything more- it was truly perfect. My guests raved about how delicious the desserts were and they will certainly not disappoint!

Betsie Gonzalez

Best crumb buns in New Jersey. If you don't get there early grab a ticket. Well worth the wait for their fresh daily homemade sweets and bread.

Paul Conte

It's like traveling back in time when quality and community were prioity

James Grable

5 stars...nuff said

Clarke Thomas

Take a ticket immediately when walking in, even if there's a short line. Hot coffee to right, ask for Cold brew from the counter. (The Cold Brew is stronger) Expect a long wait on weekends. Famous for crumb buns. Delicious danishes.

Candace Maffettone

Love it, love everything about it!

Annamaria Sutto

Crumb cake is ok

American Automotive



My favorite bakery

Kim Poirot

The best!!!

Ed Studley

The best bakery in NJ

Jeffrey Raymon

Absolutely the BEST BAKERY ON EARTH! We visit that place every time we visit the jersey shore, If you're considering going, do not hesitate! You'll never be disappointed

Zachary Meli

Top 3 crumb cake of all time! Place is amazing

Katie Smith

Friendly workers! Great assortment!

Helena Beresova

The best ever bakery, love them

Judith Romero

The best bakery! Plan on waiting along time (30+ minutes) on the weekends. Worth the wait. Glazed crumb buns are a must. As is just about everything else. Coffee roll in the microwave, Mmmmm.

Chloe Brenna

Mueller's Bakery has it all- friendly staff, delicious pastries, beautiful cakes- you name it! I've grown up going to Mueller's for as long as I can remember. The long morning wait time absolutely pays off as soon as you open the crumb cake box.

Peter Strauss

Very busy at this time of year but excellent items. Gotta get there early to avoid the crowd


Established, friendly and delicious. My wife and I bought our wedding cake getting there in 2003. We always return for donuts, coffee cake and whatever else we need. They are open in the winter so get there whenever you're in the area

Brendan Doran

Its closed ..I'm soooooooo disappointed

Lenny Stickno

Everything is off the charts if you have a problem with the offerings here you should check yourself in

Jim Valenti

The best bakery, hands down !!

John Lodico

The best crumb buns in the world! :-)

mike LaValle

Have been stopping in there for years they have some of the best crumb cake and cakes and cookies breads that you going to see on the Jersey shore

Kevin Laven

two words - crumb cake!!! the best, straight up powdered crumb cake anywhere. the glazed and filled crumb cake are also pretty well as all of their pastries (give the danties a try - even the gluten free "go bay head" cookies are awesome). go early or grab a number and be ready to wait in summer - it can be an hour plus (like 100+ plus people in front of you!)...but know that it is totally worth it which is why everyone is waiting! locals tip when it's a crazy line: get your number, walk to the beach (2 blocks) and enjoy it for 30-45 minutes, then come back for a short wait.

King Home

Best crumb buns on the planet

Brenda Kita

The best bakery ever.

john kruzik

Great bakery!!! Try anything!!

Vincent Spada

Best bakery at the Jersey shore.. donuts and crumb cake

Mark Fletcher

One of the last down home remanats of the Jersey shore. An honest to goodness old world bakery with savory fare.

Rich Squires

Must visit place at the shore for baked goods!

danielle palangio

crumb cakes here are one of the best iv ever had

tom cresci

Get there early for their crumb cake, buy 1:30 hard as a rock and dry. Much to thin for a crumb cake, dont know what all the hubbub is about..Shop & Stop much better and cheaper....

Bill Borbely

Best bakery on the Jersey shore. Amazing selection and first rate. Staff is always helpful.


Hands down the BEST crumb cake in New Jersey and maybe the world. I've been going to another bakery in lavallette for the last 32 years and getting my crumb fix their and thought that it didn't get any better than that but behold Mueller's. The crumbs are loaded with flavor and perfectly crumbly and the cake is light and delicious. The blueberry crumb cake was packed with blueberries, not just blueberry flavored goo. Perfect amount of icing and powder sugar. This place is the best I've ever had and their other pastries are stellar as well. Get their early especially if you are going on the weekend because the line can be long even before 8am.

Jason Romanosky

Love me some Muller's Crumb cake but be sure you have some cash, antiquated $10 min for credit card transactions had me scrambling. Sometimes you just want some crumb cake and coffee. $9.67 should be close enough and who carries cash anymore?

Pamela White

Beyond compare! Best crumb cake anywhere!

Lucy Banta

Crumb cake lover? Mueller's has the BEST ever. Their birthday cakes and other bakery items are all freshly baked and delicious tasting. Been going to Mueller's for more than 60 years!

gennaro guarino

All good things to say about mueller's goodies and good service. It's as good as I remember as a child. I really like everything they make. crumb cakes and apple turnovers are my favorite.

Twodiff Socks

Delish food, great service & very friendly

Nicholas Tinsley

Great designs on delicious baked goods.

colin fagan

Best crumb cake on planet Earth

Jim Thomas

Excellent bakery. Especially their crumb cake. Yum.

Jennifer Gonnello

They are the best

Terry Lynch

Service great. Crumbcake excellent!

Nikki Landerkin

Amazing, delicious and wonderful! Everything was fresh and so flavorful!!

Marilyn Ann

Crumb buns, jelly donuts and hard rolls are the BEST around.

Douglas Jayne

Great donuts and crumb cake

Stephanie Miller

Our church orders gingerbread houses and cookies every year; they are a great Christmas activity and taste wonderful. This is the first year we had to go pick up our order .. the staff was very helpful and friendly.

Richard JANSEN

This is the best bakery in the state of new Jersey

David Bishop

This bakery is the greatest. The atmosphere on the Dec 24th was great. It was great trying to find the end of the pick up line. Everyone was enjoyable to be around. We got 6 seeded rolls, 6 unseeded rolls, 6 onion rolls and a iced crumb cake. Everybody behind the counter was very helpful and pleasant to deal with. Give all the help a raise. Thanks Mueller's.

Maureen Hosie

Friendly and full of tasty choices

Sean Flukey

Decent bakery staples with a nice crumb cake. Would have liked to had less cake options and more Italian or Jewish options being on the shore of NJ.

Robin Baine

Best bakery. Crumb cake is outstanding. Everything is always fresh. We've tried a variety of items from here and never been disappointed.

William Beltle

Busy old fashioned bakery. Exceptionally friendly service. Go. You won't be disappointed.

Jenn h

Great iced coffee, good desserts. Servers can be a little nasty though

Donna Mcknight

Absolutely one of the best bakeries in Ocean County their brownies are the best with nuts for me absolutely fabulous assortment of pastries and cakes located in Bay Head New Jersey

Alphonse Balducci

Service is great and the donuts and pastries are fantastic

Janice Agro

This bakery has everything

Rosanne Perrella

Crumb cake is great

Milagros Frolich

Best Boston cream donuts on the east coast..

Rachel Hannah Polsky

Amazing selection of delicious treats, cakes, breads at extremely reasonable prices. Great iced coffee.

Dr. Andrew Presti

Hands down, the best bakery in the area. Their crumb cake alone is one of the main local attractions, second to perhaps the beach itself. Do not miss out!

Lisa Burton

Love this place. Good selection. Usually a line but it moves quickly.

Logan Dingus

Mueller's truly has the best crumb bun I have ever had. Iced or powdered, you can't go wrong with either. They also have really good cookies of all kinds and their apple turnovers are amazing. Highly reccomend going here.

Judy JudyJ

Best crumb buns ever! My bestie just sent me a crumb cake! I'm a Jersey girl that lives in Myrtle Beach SC. I'm in heaven!!!

B. Ozdogan

Popular Bakery, fresh breads, a bit crowded.

Robert Girone

Simply Devine. Theirs a reason why it's only open during the spring & summer months.

Sandy Brill

Delicious and expensive

Jerry Meaney

Love their Drizzled coffee cake

G Zagatta

Really good cakes, pastries, and cookies

GKG Squared

So delicious. A Jersey Shore staple! Staff is always so friendly and helpful..butter cookies are a must have as are donuts too! Everything is tasty. Easy parking. A+

Greg melillo

Their crumb cake is amazing

Ray Golden

Iconic establishment loved by locals.

Patricia Lubinski

Busy place. Bought a dozen. Pastries to try. If good we will b back


Special ordered a birthday cake. Drove over an hour to pick it up and despite giving the correct spelling the name was still spelt wrong. They just wiped off the misspelled part and redrew it on top. Half the cake is smooth and the rest looks uneven, completely unacceptable.

Eric Farinick

Best bakery ever def must go n 5 stars

David Stupar

This is THE BEST bakery at the Shore... hands down. They have the best crumb cake I have ever tasted.

Jenn Wong

It's a bakery that my friends go to..quitesential iconic bakery. Something's you can get here..some things no.. blueberry pound cake..- YES!! Plenty to try .& Thank goodness it's not nearby. there can be a long wait..take a #..but guess it's worth it!!

Mike D'Amico

In my opinion this is the best bakery in all of NJ. I'm just lucky enough to live in the same town. If you visit during summer hours expect long....Very long lines. Saturdays and Sundays are always the longest waits. The girls behind the counter are the most pleasant people even while dealing with a hectic crowd of vacationing families. Their cakes and cookies are amazing, but what keeps um all coming back is their crumb cakes (80%crumb 20%cake). They do have coffee and other drinks. Parking is ample across the street.

midnights moon

Awesome! Everything is always delicious and the customer service is great too!

Colleen Morton

Great bakery. Been going for years.

Jonathan Grekstas

Kind of busy at the time I was there, but fast friendly and efficient service. Got crumb cake by the piece, raspberry filled and iced, some bags of crumbs, a mini apple turnover, and a cinnamon roll. Everything was delicious!

dawn simard

What a bakery is supposed to be. Awesome homemade bread doughnuts and crumb buns. Staff efficient and friendly

Karen Greiner

Three observations: 1) grab a number in the weekends and prepare to wait; 2) crumble cake! 3) worth the wait.

Meghan Woodruff

The best iced crumbcake!!!

Deborah Ducey

Best Crumb Cakes & Banana Cream Pie ❤❤❤❤❤

Kevin Hsu

I came here based on others’ reviews of their crumb cake. Was not disappointed. I bought several boxes as gifts and the recipients were also impressed. The main reason I wanted to review them however is that their customer service is way above average for a bakery. They are staffed by young people who are attentive, patient and so friendly here! That says a lot about the care they put into everything.

Tony DelDuca

The best bakery in the universe

Charles Hoey

Friendly staff , willing to accommodate, great selection , plenty of parking nearby , best quality anywhere.

Gary M

The Best Crumb Buns and Awesome Black & White Cookie

Thomas Gallagher

Wonderful Old-Time Bakery. Exceptional Quality and Service.

Craig B

Great food, friendly staff. Can be really crowded on the weekends butttt that is because it is so good.

Peter Thompson

Awesome bakery. Haven't had a bad thing yet. They get buried on weekends so be prepared to wait. Prices are fair...$20-$25 for a dozen pastries / Danish. Basic donut choices. You can grab a cup of coffee and they've got 2 or 3 cafe tables too. Plenty of parking and if you're inclined, the Bridge street entrance to the beach is two short blocks away.

Gary Domke

Very good work a large selection of pastries and cakes


It was my 1st time and my last time to this establishment I walked in the teenagers behind the counter were happy to assist me in my selections And as they were Answering my questions the old lady with the Gray here became rude and told me try another store would she need it be involved because I would have selected and I did select something else but I can assure you all never be back to that store again as a matter of fact the family of 4 that walked outside the store said that he were a bit grumpy this morning I said he was downright rude and that's not customer service if you can't deal with people early in the morning you shouldn't be working

Ed Roncin

Crumb cake. Nuff said

Christina Bello

Every time I visit the shore, I HAVE to stop by. Their crumb cake is just as good today as it was 25 years ago when I lived here. Plus, the employees are super friendly and helpful. If you're at the Jersey Shore, you need to stop by!

Carol Mcgee

The Best

Chinenye Anako

The crumb cake was delicious and the cookies were delicious.

William Ryan

Absolutely the best bakery at the Shore. Everything is so fresh and delicious. Their crumb cake is practically world famous. I love their powdered jelly donuts (closest thing to Hoffman's anywhere) and their danishes are large and out of this world, my fave being the prune danish. I can't even get into their cakes, pies, cupcakes and cookies right now. Next time! And this review was written by a former baker who should know good stuff when he tries it! Enjoy!

Patricia Bader

Old Time Quality bakery! Great crumb cake, doughnuts, breads and cakes. I feel like i am stepping back in time. The staff are pleasant and helpful and you won't be disappointed!!

Joanne Peters

THE BEST crumb cake hands down! Worth the wait!

Will Snook

I have been here a few times and always found something new and fun for the kids! Also the bread is unmatched!!

Kerry Dunkirk

Love the baked goods but so expensive!

Douglas Tyler

Delicious fresh food what else can you say!!!

Ashley Fagan

Best bakery in Jersey!!

Mable Stark

The almond horns are a must have! Place is a little expensive, but totally worth it

Kenneth Kelly

The only bakery open year-round on a barrier island still maintains high quality goodies.

Dana Valentino

Great selections, immaculately clean, fantastic staff, and delicious food

Joe Todd

They make the best crumb cake. Small bakery with excellent selection. Friendly service, family owned.

Elaine Corbley

We love the baked goods, the staff and the town!

Kristina Castaldo

I love this place! A little piece of my heart resides there. Crumb buns and italian cookies is where it's at yall. My nonnie and grandma owned a house right on the ocean in Lavalette, and went here daily. As a child I remember waiting in line with my grandma so excited because she'd always sneak me a cookie before we got home with them. Muellers is one of the best memories I have of New Jersey. There is nothing like a crumb bun literally nothing. You can even order them online which I have done in the past and they are just as amazing as I remember them. Powdered is my favorite but iced is delicious too. Pop them in the microwave for a few seconds and you will be in heavennnn. Hopefully I will order soon when I have the spare money haha. But seriously try this place you wont regret it. I always remember everyone being so sweet, treating every customer like family!!!! Thank you for being part of so many amazing memories.

Patrik H

Mueller's is a Jersey Shore landmark for generations of locals, summer residents, and vacationers. My family has been going here for decades upon decades and the bakery remains dedicated to making the most scrumptious crumb cake in the world. If you are new to Mueller's, make sure you try the crumb cake...they also excel with their cookies and Danish (and really everything else too). A summer morning tradition in Bay Head is to grab your bicycle, get here early (trust me), grab a number, and take your treats to the beach or lake for a morning snack. It does not get any better than Mueller's! Enjoy, you will be hooked for life!

Mike Catino

Wow what can you say about your favorite bakery at the Jersey Shore. If you need anything in the baked goods category from cookies to Birthday cakes, or your maybe you just want a brownie or granola bar, Mueller's is the place. There are not allot of mom and pop bakeries left in NJ so this one is well worth the try. The best bakery at the Jersey Shore. You won't be disappointed but be fore warned during the summer you should be prepared to wait. Staff is great so things move fast.

Kathy Decrescenzo

Only problem is the morning wait. Service friendly accurate and as fast as can be with system in place. Quality is the best.

Michael Magee


William Bennet

This is a local favorite that gets busy very fast so the best time to get the best selections are always first thing in the morning. When you walk in, get your ticket and you can stay browsing the large selection of bread, cookies, muffins, donuts & cakes. They have such a large selection of great items that it's almost impossible to say which is the best. The staff is very friendly and helpful. Definitely a great place to stop and highly recommended.

Business Hours of Mueller's Bakery in New Jersey



Mueller's Bakery en New Jersey
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Park Bakery (CLOSED FOR T...
Bakery - New Jersey


Dulce De Leche Bakery
Dulce De Leche Bakery
Bakery - New Jersey


Prato Bakery
Prato Bakery
Bakery - New Jersey


Lyndhurst Pastry Shop
Lyndhurst Pastry Shop
Bakery - New Jersey


Swiss Chalet Bakery & Cafe
Swiss Chalet Bakery & Cafe
Bakery - New Jersey