Reviews of Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery (Bakery)

Anita G

Amazing friendly service, The snickerdoodle was to die for and cake in a cup had the best cream i have ever laid my tounge on..

Rob M

Too expensive for what you get. Taste is good and everything looks nice as well. Friendly service.

Chris M

Great pastries. Amazing coffee. All around great place. It's all small batch and made daily so prices are a bit higher but it's good for a treat. Definitely a Brooklyn spot in Jersey.

Linda Robles

Wonderful pastries, decadent desserts, delicious coffee, and family-friendly customer service! Renee is nothing short of a pastry genius. She puts so much thought and love into her food, and it shows! Keep doing what you're doing!

Katelyn Hlad

Very good, love the variety and everything tastes amazing. But whenever they are helping a customer, they almost fully ignore them to have a conversation with another customer or employee. Also whenever they don't have labels so I ask what a certain thing is specifically, one specific woman always acts so annoyed. Be a little friendlier and attentive to the customer you're currently helping.

Karina Mena

Yummy one of a kind pastries, amazing coffee, awesome customer service..

Globaldhd

I can't stop going to Erie. Everything is fresh and home made. All taste good. Staff are so friendly. Rutherford is a beautiful town and safe. Nice atmosphere. Highly recommend

Alexander Friedman

I love this place so much. Wonderful, friendly staff, great coffee, and honestly some of the best baked goods I've ever had, hands down.

Ron Ehlert

Just absolutely amazing food

Matt Spohn

Amazing little shop. Great baked goods and savory little pies! Coffee is on point and everyone is super friendly. Glad I stumbled across this on my travels and will definitely be back!

Sheila massoni

Tried the new shortbread sandwich cookie that was mentioned in Sunday's record it is so delicious

Joe Guz

Love everything from here! Citrus oil cake is amazing!

Julia Cho

I highly recommend! It's a quaint and homey coffee shop. The banana loaf is delicious and not too sweet. Their coffee is from Cafe Grumpy in Brooklyn and the staff are so welcoming. Barista Joyce takes great care of her customers!

Jeff Apollo

Nice little cozy place... Friendly staff and lots of goodies... I'm definitely going back.

Jermaine Coe

Quaint bakery with delightful pastries. I had the pleasure of trying the olive oil citrus pastry, which can only be described as the perfect balance of sweet and tart. The best is that they are cooked into mini Bundt cakes allowing for your personal piece heaven with no need to share! 10/10 Would recommend to anyone with two eyes and a nose.

Shane Owen

The team at Erie never cease to amaze me with the treats they come up with. Coupled together with a friendly group of people and calming environment, Erie is a must visit location for those in the area.

Katia M

Amazing! Tried almost everything this bakery has to offer and like it to the tiniest crumb. They offer sweet and savory pastries, classic coffee drinks and very nice and friendly customer service. Place is pretty small but has its unique charm and character. Must try!

Matthew Kuznia

Great coffee, delicious food, and a friendly staff. Had no clue it existed for the longest time. Definitely a hidden gem just 50 feet off Park Ave.

Mike Collins - DFMS

The best hands down in the area.

Maggie Elbaum

Awesome, cute, little coffee place with baked goodies to die for!! Service is great, staff is super friendly and sweet.

Mike Gomes

Lovely bakery with a great aesthetic & wonderful staff. Very charming. My favorite bakery in NJ.

Victoria Zurla

I have been going to Erie since they opened and they never disappoint. The cakes and custom goodies are truly works of art, and besides looking aesthetically beautiful, they are delicious! Each day brings new treats, classics, and spins on favorites. Renee and her staff have done almost all our family events since they opened, from my baby shower to my husband’s going away, to our son’s first birthday where Renee hand crafted designer donuts, cookies, and the most amazing cake to fit the theme we had created. More than that, even on the craziest days in the shop, the staff is beyond caring and attentive. We are so spoiled with having such an amazing bakery and coffee shop right near us!

Michelle Holmes

Small, cute place with delicious food! Warm and cozy environment. Great Customer service. Not a lot of sitting, but if you a can score one of the four chairs by the window it's so relaxing.

Bryan Kahrar

Great espresso, unique and delicious baked goodies. Did I mention that the espresso is great?

Adison Essig

This place is amazing. Really a gem, other bakeries in the area don't compare.

Frank Cantelmi

Great pastries, breakfast sandwiches and coffee

Jeremy Connors

Renee is really fantastic. Everything I've had tastes wonderful and she made us a smashing wedding cake that our guests still talk about nearly 2 years later.

j k

i had this cake with some kind of crumbs as pie crust... it was delicious

Aracely Bolanos

Magnificent!!

Will Martinez

Wow, Erie bakery is a MUST try!! I worked in a higher end pastry shop in Arlington, VA in my younger days and those were really good pastries, but my expectations were blown away when I had Erie. Their pastries are incredible!!! You can tell they take pride in the work they do, I'm coming here again!

Natalia Lopez

Love this place! My family and I have been going here for years. Whenever I have a birthday party I order a chocolate cake with raspberry filling from here and their snickerdoodle cookies are actually to die for. You can not go wrong buying anything from this bakery. It's also nice to support smaller local businesses that are family owned/ operated. They are always so incredibly nice!

Debra Florez

Delicious pies! The Apple Crumble is the best I’ve ever had and they’re simply beautiful!

Douglas Taylor

Excellent pastries and coffee

Jason Eagleson

Grab a fresh cup of coffee and a pastry. I like that the pastries aren't huge, just higher end and good.

R.J. M.

Fabulous...Imagine the best...then go and discover that it is even better than that...so so good : )

Julie Costello

This place has every dessert you could ever dream of. Super clean on the inside, great customer service. The taste of each dessert i've tried so far is like a morsel of heaven itself. Best bakery i've ever been to by far. Eat here, you won't regret it.

Rebecca Natal

Excellent customer service and the iced coffee is the best I have ever had and I've had a lot of coffee in my day. Can't wait to nosh on some of the goodies I brought home.

April Caruso

Such an adorable coffee shop!!! Coffee is amazing and their pastries and deserts are decadent and delicious!!! So so cute!!

Renee Faris

We're always trying to do our best at this bakery! If you're not happy tell us

robert p

Great little place. The olive oil citrus cake is delicious.

Reg & Ali Duncan

Great latte and unique variety of pasteries. Also have a variety of gluten free items.

Tim Hand

A bit of 'Brooklyn' found in Rutherford! Great coffee and a huge slice of banana bread made my morning. Super friendly staff.

Jeremy Rosario

Good coffee, great service, awesome pastries and baked goods. Everything I've tried here is delicious.

David Abramsky

Just had the best slice of banana walnut loaf ever! Fresh, still warm, large slice, lots of walnuts and sweet crispy edges. Top-notch soy latte. Friendly staff.

Abraham Awad

The citrus olive oil cake is a must try! Also, they have some of the best banana bread I’ve ever had. I’ve never had a bad experience with any of their pastries but I haven’t tried them all. Their coffee is also pretty good. Cappuccino is good as well. They also have a very friendly, helpful staff!

Cameron M

Best coffee spot in Rutherford! Amazing food with passionate staff.

Framers-dot-com NYC & NJ Custom Framing & Printing

Friendly staff and delicious pie. She offered me a sample of their sweet potato cayenne pie. It's unexpectedly good. The coffee was delicious.

Madison Hatch

quite possibly the greatest baked goods I've ever eaten. Luckily my mother doesn't have a google account, so I am free to say the owner beats her fare and square. Good coffee, beautiful interior, and always walk out with a smile. I would go to the place and no place else. Erie rocks.

Ramzi Faris

The bakery is out of this world!!! Absolutely Spectacular! Great service,and amazing food. So happy that Renee is doing what she loves and sharing it with all of us..

Carlos Perez

Fresh Bake Goods, Great Staff and Must To Place To Visits

Abigail Rubin

I love this place! Pastries are always delicious and interesting, the coffee is the best in the area too! I feel at home whenever I stop by, everyone at the shop is friendly and helpful. And don’t forget to get a classic chocolate chip cookie before you leave

Dave Drysdale

Awesome coffee shop with super friendly staff and to die for bakery treats. Couldn't recommend this place enough! (This is not, however, a great place to bring your computer and work all day as it is a small shop. This is a great coffee shop, not a great library)

deejay40 .

What a cute, cozy little shop! It's a small batch bakery with four stools inside and two benches outside. Just had a lemon meringue tart and an apple crumb cake with a Black Cherry & Ginger iced tea. All delicious. $7 min charge for credit cards. The benches out front face the sun in the afternoon so it's a nice place to sit and enjoy your sweets. Worth a visit.

Exquisite Woman

What a delightfully hip and welcoming bakery. It reminds me of something you would see on a Lifetime channel movie. Everything looked so perfect I wanted one of everything. I ordered a cortado along with a ham parmesan and leek scone. This slightly buttery scone had litte nuggets of ham, mixed with the refined finishing of leeks and parmesan. This is the best-est creamy compact breakfast you will ever eat. Another awesome treat was the sneaky rosemary and thyme shortbread cookie. The pungent complex blend of savory spices are mellowed out with the shortbread base. There were many choices and such lovely helpful staff Ms. Aubrey was happy to help me pick up several items. Put this place on your must visit list!

antonino chetta

Cool bakery with unique treats that will satisfy your sweet tooth and caffeinated needs. A must stop if your in Rutherford, NJ

Priya Vin

Love this place. Everything is fresh and full of flavor

Adam Consovoy

Best Bakery this side of the Hudson River. Always ask for what new and interesting, Renee never disappoints. The $5 coffee and slice of pie is the best deal you will find around.

Grace Meharg

Friendly service, delicious pastries, and overall pleasant vibes. I recommend the snicker doodle :)

MariaCristina Garcia

Friendly service, good prices, baked goods that will not disappoint! You CAN NOT find the flavor mixes elsewhere. This place will make your palate jump with happiness!!

Jonathan Layme

Great pastries, coffee is delicious. A lot of unique items. A must try

Timothy Krupa

Asked for a non standard but very Italian espresso and they gave it a try and it was great! Wow, add to that the gluten free pastry/cookies and I'm a confirmed customer.

Nicole Panico

They Were Closed When They Were Supposed To Be Open.

J. Jasmine Lee

Inventive and unique baked goods that are satisfying and not loaded with sugar. Only gourmet-quality items available here. I believe they only serve Café Grumpy coffee here. Grumpy coffee is one of the best around, and I am so glad I can get my fix so close to home. Keep up the great work! Hope the town is smart enough to appreciate your quality goods.

Kristen LaBarbera

Delicious items and friendly staff

Alex Doumas

Everything in this place is unreal.

Boris Kavlakov

Masterfully crafted baked goodies!!!

Drew Lasater

We visit multiple times a month besides amazing coffee the variety and quality of everything they make is amazing. This is the best bakery in the area by far.

Alyssa A Epperly

I went there this morning because this is where I'm planning to get my wedding cake made even though I've never actually been there (Yeah, I know). So I just wanted to go inside and see really, and I just only bought a Snickerdoodle (my favorite) with butterscotch and my fiance bought a Handpie and they were both SO GOOD I never want to anyone else's snickerdoodle again.

Michael Mangual

Delicious bakery items. All the stuff I ate was great although this place is crazy expensive. Got a few items and it came out to 22 bucks, it was good though so just be mindful that it’s definitely a pricey bakery. A star is knocked off because the chai latte was subpar compared to everything else.

John R.

Great pastries but woman at the register was extremely rude.

Robert N

On 2/23/18 I bought a lg coffee $3. Price almost like at Starbucks but a taste of this coffee is far behind, it’s closer to a Bustelo coffee, if not more sour