Reviews of Three Sisters Cake Shop (Bakery)

Victoria Nakis

My husband and I booked our wedding cake with Three Sister's Cake Shop and it was the best choice we made! I've used them before for small orders at work or cupcakes for Thanksgiving and had a great experience. So, naturally, when we got married, they were the first people on our list. They were super reasonably priced, and gave us plenty of options to sample at our tasting. They absolutely nailed the cake design we wanted; once I saw it, it literally looked like it came straight from Pintrest. We had a 2-tier cake with 2 different flavors and gold "paint" dripping from the top with some dried flowers. It was so pretty. They are super responsive and so nice to work with. Most importantly, it was probably the best cake I've eaten in my life. You should absolutely use these ladies!

George

Best cake shop in the seacoast, by far! What they can do with cakes is unreal. They did an amazing job the times we ordered from them. My wife and I love it when we find shops like this. Highly recommended!

Kayla Flaherty

Three Sisters Cake shop made my son’s first birthday cake, and it was absolutely amazing! Everything from ordering the cake to picking it up was made so easy by their great customer service. The cake design was incredible! We specifically requested no fondant, so all the sculpting was with butter cream and it was just perfect! And the taste was hands down the best cake I’ve ever had. My family and friends are still talking about how amazing the cake was. We couldn’t have been happier with Three Sisters and will absolutely be using them again for the next occasion!

Annika Chambers

Very helpful and nice, did a cake tasting and their cakes were very yummy!

Sara Haggerty

Specialty cupcakes were gorgeous!

Sarah Clark

Highly recommend this place! We ordered our small wedding cake here by the end of last year and it was AMAZING. I wanted a "naked cake" with many fruit in it and I must say, it turned out perfectly! It was really delicious and looked great. Their prices are totally reasonable. I'm more than happy we ordered our cake here.

Shauna Savoy

Thank you so much for making my daughter’s birthday special when I couldn’t be there! And she absolutely loved the vanilla cupcake with maple buttercream frosting ❤️

Cord Tocci

Simply delicious. The cupcakes are everything you could want in a cupcake. The cookies are soft and just right... Their cake pops are tasty... Can't wait to try more of their goodies!

Shawna Kozicki

Cake is amazing!

Kristen Cuneo

Despite the fact that neither I nor my spouse are usually big cake/cupcake fans, we LOVED Three Sisters Cake Shop cupcakes. Went to the tasting and ate up every bit of sample! At our wedding, we heard soooo many people exclaim that the cupcakes were amazing! All of our gluten-free attendees were besides themselves with joy over the gluten free cupcakes - those were the first cupcakes to run out! We discovered that most people who had 1 cupcake ended up having a 2nd one later in the evening because they were so good! Cupcakes were delivered on time and setup was beautiful. Most delightful moment came at end of the night, after reception, when we went back to our suite and discovered that 4 of the cupcakes had been set aside for them by event team! They made a delicious 2nd dessert and next-day breakfast :)

Beverly Kannengieszer

Three Sister's wonderfully delicious carrot cake which I purchased for my sisters' 65thwas so good that my guests wanted to sneak some home. Scrumptious! You won't be disappointed.

Jonathan Tripp

I have been a customer at Three Sisters for years now. We love their cakes and every birthday we have has a cake from Three Sisters featured at it. That’s five plus cakes a year. Absolutely delicious, beautiful cakes.

Diann Sapien

Always a win here!!!! Returning customer here!!

Janith Bergeron

We enjoyed dozens of delicious cupcakes at our son's college graduation party. Holly and Sara were delightful to work with and great customer service.

Ruth ann Stevens

Awesome Bakery! The Cake and Cupcakes for my daughter's Bridal Shower were so delicious and looked amazing! Thank you so much!

Nick Bellows

We visited for a wedding consultation. The women that met with us was very friendly and professional. We tried half a dozen different cake/frosting combos and they were all really good.

Jessica Fillmore

Fast, friendly service and, the icing on the cake? BEST cupcakes ever!

saroj fleming

Beautiful and delicious cakes for my son’s bday 2 years in a row!

Seacoast Reviews

This place is amazing. Made a special cake for a special event recently. First of all, the cake looked exactly how we wanted it to look. It was absolutely delicious and the price was fair. Will recommend to friends/family. Will be back for special events in the future. Thanks again!

T Allen

They are friendly, hospitable and very helpful. I am beyond excited to have them make our wedding cake in October! Thank you for your hospitality!

Jocelyne Winter

Absolutely loved the cake they did for our wedding a couple weeks ago. It looked amazing and they were able to give us an awesome design for our theme (Harry Potter) that was also in our price range and affordable. Above all, the cake was delicious and so many of our guests came up to us to tell us they loved it. They are great people to work with and I am so happy my husband and I went with them for our wedding!

Kayla McLean

So amazing !!! So easy to work with. Booked our wedding Cake/Cup cakes and I can't wait to eat them !!! Thanks again

Royce L.

This shop is unique for the reason that their cakes is not only beautifully designed, they also taste good! Many people like the cakes.

Nicole Lopes

Got cupcakes for my parents 60th and they were perfect! Absolutely delicious. I usually get their cupcakes at Fiddlehead and was glad I decided to order with them. Will definitely use in the future for cake/cupcake needs!

Heidi Locke

The best cake and cupcakes ever

Daniel Johnson

I highly recommend Three Sister's Cake Shop. We chose a beautiful cake for my wedding in Southern Maine. They were professional, kind, and easy to work with. The cake was beautiful, delicious, and arrived in great condition at our venue.

Tina Libby

My first time ordering from you and I am blown away by the work you guys do!! The cake was absolutely amazing and I will highly recommend you to anyone I know that's looking for an awesome tasty cake:) I will definitely be back for more! Keep up the great work

Tamera Harriman

Cupcakes Awesome

Ralph Schott

Not a bakery

Ruth Kenneway

Ordered wedding cake and cupcakes! They were perfect! Thank you