Reviews of Nellie Custom Cakes (Bakery)

2 NE 69th Hwy, Kansas City, MO 64119, United States

Average Rating:


We've got the opinions of people like you who are buying the products of Nellie Custom Cakes (Bakery) around Kansas area.

Currently this firm gets a rating of 4.4 out of 5 and that rating was based on 25 reviews.

As you can read, it reaches an reviews average is very good, and it is founded on a very high number of opinions, so we can say that the evaluation is quite credible. If many people have bothered to evaluate when they've done well, is that it works.

You know that we do not usually bother to place evaluations when they are good and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery is included in the category of Wedding bakery.

Where is Nellie Custom Cakes?

REVIEWS OF Nellie Custom Cakes IN Kansas

Andy McGee

Literally, the best custom cake place in the Kansas City area. We asked them to do a cake for our Church Grand Opening. The price was right, the cake was tasty, and they made it exactly like we wanted it. For any of your custom cake needs go to Nellie's Custom Cakes. Andy McGee, Lead Pastor, Trinity Family Midtown Church of the Nazarene

Kira 123

Needed sheet cake for my husband's military promotion. Cheryl at Nellie's patiently worked with me on creating the design I wanted and at a VERY affordable price. Many people commented on how cool the cake looked and wanted to know who made it. Also, I don't know if this is the norm, but I only gave a week and a half notice and they were able to accommodate me. Nellie seems to be a cake decorating machine! ;) Will definitely recommend her to others and go back myself in the future!

RockChalkRobin GO KU

The cake was Perfect!!!

Kimberly Newby

Sarah Lynch

I've had nellies cakes before from family members and parties but when I went to go order my own for my baby shower this was the worst customer service experience and pricing I've ever came a crossed. I'm pretty well experienced with cakes, so they wanted to price me $25 for fondant booties, $25 for a fondant ribbon, $30 for icing roses and that's just the decorations cake alone was $105. This cake came out to be $182 for 30 people. These pricing are overrated and not worth how rude and disrespectful they were to me and my friend. Never recommending them again.

Tisha Anyanike

Great custom cakes! Small place with very personalized service.

Zach Coffman

This place is awesome, we get all our cakes here. Always tastes good too.

Olivia Williams

Been using Nellie's for years... I think they do a great job at making cakes. Love that when you walk in you can smell fresh cakes baking, also love that it is a small locally owned shop. I do think the prices are a bit pricey but you have to take in account that these are handmade items- they aren't bought and placed on the cake. I really appreciate all the time they've put into the cakes I've ordered over the years. My parents even ordered from them when I was a kid- sweet 16 , countless other birthdays and my graduation cake and cupcakes! Now I order for baby showers, and my own kids' bdays. Family tradition for us and every time we've ordered I've been blown away.

Mila J

Over priced for the quality and the waste of money on gas. The cake was dry, not moist as it should have been at all. Attached is what I wanted and what I got. The bottle was way too big, the name too small and the baby should've been the size of the bottle. The kids enjoyed it, which is what matters I guess. However, would not recommend.

Sara Andrews

We ordered my son’s fifth birthday cake from here and were blown away by how amazing and delicious it was. We will definitely be ordering again!

Erin rheuark

Janette Bojorquez

There was a women that gave me attitude!!! Like I get it chill out Be respectful to your clients!

Brooke Rollison

We used Nellie's Custom Cakes for our wedding. The cake was delicious and so well done. The buttercream was just the perfect amount. Plus, we just celebrated our one year anniversary and let me tell you: the cake STILL tasted good. It held up so well. We were so impressed!

Emily Curry

This little bakery makes tasty, beautiful cakes!! My wedding cake came out precisely how I'd wanted it to. You can bet I'll be using them again in the future!

Kellie R

AMAZING! The cake is beautiful!

Errie Raasch

Best cakes ever!!! We love this place!

savannah lange

best looking and best tasting cake i ever had!!! will get all cakes and cookies from here!

Melanie Herdman

Our wedding cake was beautiful AND delicious, or so I am told, I only had a bit that my husband and I fed to each other. But, the top that was saved for our first anniversary was DELICIOUS a whole year later! I was expecting it to be dry. I was super excited to get to finally have a piece of my wedding cake! Nellie's was great to provide sample cakes to decide on flavor. We ended up getting chocolate, but what I really wanted after sampling was the strawberry swirl. Both flavors were delicious, as well as the others we sampled. I also got a baby shower cake for friend's shower, and I gave them a picture of how the nursery was going to be decorated, and they made the cake look like the nursery. It was so cute and also delicious!

Mallery Zion

Great people and memorable desserts. I have memories of their makes as far back as I can remember. I always loved going into the sweet smelling shop and picking out cute designs!

Kathy Soule

Nellie's has made my granddaughter's birthday cake for 5 years. They are always delicious and beautiful. The lady that took our order today was the greatest. Love Nellie Custome Cakes

Richard Soule

Jennifer coffman

Best cake place in Kansas City. Cakes look good and TASTE good. Some expensive cake places use cake mix boxes and charged hundred s of dollars(we can tell people, we can tell) Not this place though.

Kelly Watson

Dub Giltner

The best did my Son's sock monkey themed smash cake as well as the birthday cake for his first birthday!!!!! Thanks for our Sock Monkeys and accommodating our short notice

Megan Montgomery

Nice staff and good cake. :)

Business Hours of Nellie Custom Cakes in Kansas



Nellie Custom Cakes en Kansas
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Ashleigh's Bakeshop
Ashleigh's Bakeshop
Bakery - Kansas

Pie shop

Bloom Baking Company
Bloom Baking Company
Bakery - Kansas


McLain's Market Lawrence
McLain's Market Lawrence
Bakery - Kansas


Boulevard Bakery
Boulevard Bakery
Bakery - Kansas


Elvira's Cakes
Elvira's Cakes
Bakery - Kansas