Reviews of Taylor's Bakery (Bakery)

Alex O.

Yes. Just...yes!

Amber Johnson

Taylor's Bakery has the best cakes for any occasion.

Amanda Collins

Fair prices on all their products!

Jared G

Angel food cake is to die for and donut wholes are the best there are!

Nate Scheblo

Pretty solid donuts, maybe not the best I've ever had, but pretty good. Enjoyed the packaging, nice box with string tied around it. Busy place on a Saturday morning. I would like to try the cookies some day.

Drift Taxi

Ehhh.

Anna Hoover

I ordered the cake for my baby shower from here. It was exactly what I asked for, ready on time, and fresh and delicious! Very pleased

Jay Sisson

Great Bakery excellent products

Jacob Hoffman

Very fresh and delicious

Lisa Hastings-Smith

Cake donuts and donut holes cannot be beat. A bit pricey, but so delicious!

Megan Snoke

Cake bites are kinda greasy, but the cookies are so good! Tons of selection! It's hard to choose!

JS Williams

Only the best. Seriously, it’s the best. I wish I could give it more than 5 stars!! Love this place!! They are beyond kind each time I walk in.

Scott Mckenzie

Donuts were great but didn't have a variety and was out of Glace yeast at 845 in the morning so I was a little disappointed

Jumoke A.

It was very friendly and the baked goods were delicious!

BRIDGET Grider

Love Taylor's Bakery

Susan Schwab

I love Taylor's bakery However, they should make more chocolate topped doughnuts.

Joel Belyew

Great cakes, and other treats too

Greg Hess

Yum yum

Jim Dawg

They dont tell you about sale specials unless you ask. I ordered a dozen doughnut holes at full price. On the way out the door, an associate told another customer that they were buy one dozen get one free. No mention of this when I checked out or even ordered. Not a huge deal but little things like this are what make the difference between a great company and a good one. Cakes there are the best, doughnuts are a little to pricey for my taste. Look up other local (Lebanon) doughnut shops for cheaper options and better quality.

Brandon Whittington

Always good

Linda Harris

Taylors Bakery is one of the best ... so much to choose from .. and all delicous! They also work with you on special orders. Even made us special dog bone cookies for an event!

Bob Geis

I love Taylor's. We went there after lunch for treats! It was great. Get there early if you want their cinnamon rolls.

Brian Fuerst

I love their cakes. Their icecream is disgusting. There is no flavor to it. I got the flavor of the month that is supposed to be blueberry, strawberry, and lemon. The colors are fake looking and all three colors tasted the same. The cannoli I bought the shell was soft, not crisp. The cake I paid $20 dollars for was on special for $6 if you did not place an advanced order. I might be back.

Laura Strick

Taylor’s bakery in Fishers’s 116th street is disappointing in taste, selection, and service. I will not be coming back to this Taylor’s. I live in fishers but I will gladly go out of my way and go to the original Taylors Bakery on 62nd and Allisonville when I need a delicious always fresh tasty treat.

Jeannine Waldock

I have been a loyal customer since 1977. You cannot beat their cakes. Period. But........I have updated my review and dropped them down to 1 star. Their cakes are still excellent, but I went in the other day. No one was busy. No customers but me. I purchased a single 4" cake that says happy birthday. I wanted it to say over the top Welcome Boss. There was even a woman standing there with icing. They refused. I said write over. No. Please. No. You would have thought I asked them to redo the darn thing. They ruined my surprise. Really??

Jenny Cozad

Everything at Taylor's will satisfy you. From donuts to cookies and cakes, I love everything from Taylor's. My favorite is their jelly donuts and iced sugar cookies.

Ann Galloway

Absolutely scrumptious chocolate cake with personalized icing.

L. P.

Today donuts we're extremely dry....

Ted Baker

A sugar high worth having!!!

Claire Stuckey

Taylor's is by far my favorite. That's where I ordered my wedding cake years ago and just last week bought cakes for my son's first birthday. I was amazed they took a special order the evening before. I ordered his cakes Friday afternoon to pick up Saturday morning. We buy every family birthday cake there, just out of the ones they have in the case daily. Both the white cake and the chocolate are awesome.

Joni Heredia

The only bakery I use! Expert bakers and very nice staff. Our graduation cake was beautiful and delicious. I highly recommend Taylor's to everyone.

Melissa Hinman

I grew up right around the corner from a bakery. Also being a baker I know good sweets when I eat them. Everything I have tried from Taylor's is wonderful. I really wish they we're open Sunday, that is the only thing I can find wrong. Which is the reason they got 4 stars and not 5.

Alex Fiala

First time customer, I ordered a half dozen donuts for my family on a Saturday morning. Everyone was pleased with how delicious and fresh they were. Lovely place with friendly staff. Easy to see how they've been around over 100 years! This place is GREAT!

Curtis Larson

Taylor's Bakery is very easy to work with and they make the best deserts! Will definitely go back.

Jacqueline Lamboley

Awesome goodies and great service

Lynn Prest

Best

Teresa Lee

Great

Misty Smith

Best donut holes in the history of forever!!!!

Amy Mertz

What can I say? My hometown bakery with delicious bakert treats. Best cakes and donuts!

Melissa Scholz

We love Taylor's! Everything here is delicious!

Dave Copp

Products always fresh.

Michael McGee

It was a wonderful place to buy from. I enjoyed the atmosphere, great customer service, and just so outgoing staff.

Tina Turk

A bit expensive but my cake looked and tasted amazing

Lauren Smith

The strawberry angel food cake with that fresh strawberry icing?! Oh my goodness, it is so delicious! I could’ve eaten the whole cake in one sitting. Best cake I’ve ever had.

Adam A.

Great Everytime.

Dee Reese

Lemon squares and the Chocolate chip cookie ball with rich ganache in the center. Soooo good. Nice place, good service but wish those lemon squares were bigger. Don't get the popcorn though...always stale.

Donna Klein

This is the first time I've visited the Taylor's Bakery since the 70s and I lived near 62nd and Allisonville Road I was at the doctor and I knew Taylor was near there so I stopped in and bought myself a bunch of treats it is it's a great store and bakery and I will go back the people who work there were very friendly and helpful and I bought some wonderful treats.

Bill Smith

Asked for yeast donuts. Heavy, devoid of flavor, and very little sugar coating (only on one side). Comparing to Krispy Kreme donuts. This place had no apple fritters (1st request-choice). Its called a bakery, but if you want a real bakery, go to Carmel and try Jacks. Won't be back to this place and pay $1.25 for a hunk of dough.

Kelly Snyder

My all time favorite place to get birthday cake! The icing is divine and cake is delicious. I take the kiddos here as a special treat and they always have a great time finding something for their sweet tooth. friendly staff!

Jessica Cockrum

This is a nice bakery. There are a large selection of baked goods in the case. There are common items, like chocolate chip cookies, beautifully decorated sugar cookies, eclairs, cupcakes, donuts, etc to more exotic items and traditional seasonal bakes, like Hot Cross Buns at Easter. There is always something new you are going to want to try. The angel food cakes are delicious and they have different flavors that cycle through. My kids love the sugar cookies. It's definitely worth checking out!

Greg White

Their holiday cakes are fantastic

Josh Richardson

Everything here is amazing. Friendly staff.

Karen Muldoon Hess

Tasty donuts, cookies and other baked treats!

Smitha Puthenchira Thomas

Awesome bakery. Totally loved it.

Ryan DeBenedittis

Best cakes ever

Gabriel Matthews

New customer to Taylor's and I have only been there a couple of times. But sampled just about everything, I like sweets and it's all good, especially the chocolate ganache cake.

Becky Watkins

Great selection! Very helpful staff!

Sam Cridlin

Eclairs worth the drive

jenn6116

Taylor's is a wonderful bakery! Everything is delicious and the service is always amazing!

Sarah Penquite

Amazing cakes!

Rob Amy

Always good

T

Delicious treats, the chocolate cheesecake is amazing!!

Tribal Beat

Bleh. This place is really overrated. Their donuts and pastries are really overpriced and not that special. I guess they're known for their cakes, but I've never gotten one. Avoid the smaller pastries if you come here.

Sarah Dooley

They have the most amazing food, donut holes, and anything else. Great prices. Family owned business.

BETH Taylor

Too many things to choose from! Out of the Angel food cakes tho!

Janis Detmer

Love the Angel food cakes, flavors rotate, check the calender on the web site. Also love the deep fried danish!

Tim Green

Great coffee cake, angel food cake and more, always friendly

Tarik Rabie

We used to Taylor’s Bakery to cater a small cake and donuts for our wedding. I can't say enough good things about Taylor’s Bakery. They've been around for over 100 years and it's clear they have it figured it out. We put in our order 2 weeks before the wedding, the whole process took less than an hour, and was very affordable. They even had a donut stand we could rent, when other bakeries typically require you to purchase/rent your own. This made everything so easy for us. We ended up with a small carrot cake with custom Harry Potter decorations on it and a variety of donuts and donut holes for our guests. Taylor’s staff arrived at the venue on time and helped set up the donut stand. This was one of the biggest hits at our wedding, as you would expect everything tasted delicious! I'm so glad we chose Taylor’s Bakery for our wedding I highly recommend them for any of your dessert needs.

Jorge Trujillo

Pan, galletas, donas y dulces, todo delicioso

Brian M. Dotlich

Everything A-ok

CARLOS MOORE

Normally everything is fresh except today. I picked up an red velvet cake and seemed like it had been sitting around for several day or more. Very dry

Neena H

Amazing quality and always the friendliest service. Everything is DELICIOUS. They have the most perfect tiny birthday cakes about 5" across. You need to go there!

Julie Venzlauskas

Very friendly staff!! First time customer and will be going back!

Jennifer Koranda-Niesse

We only get birthday cake from Taylor's Bakery

Jeremy Lynn

No better place in town for donuts and cakes. Excellent.

Tori Montes

I love Taylor's it is the best and I recommend them to everyone I know and then some... Their cakes ,cheesecakes and cookies are mouth watering and not to mention their pastries... Five star hands down!

Keith N

Good selection. Somewhat pricey...

lindsey hadden

The yellow cakes are amazing! The donut holes

Victoria Franklin

I contacted Taylor's to have gender reveal cupcakes custom made and they did a wonderful job! Not only were they delicious but the inside pink filling was discreetly concealed! I will definitely be back!

Judy Bauerle

They made our 50th Anniversary cake. Everyone loved it. They did a great job.

Sara Bolinger

I decided last minute to buy a ton of doughnuts from Taylor's on 116th for the Fisher's PD and they completely came through and then some. Everyone is always friendly and helpful when we visit and the food is amazing. The huge chocolate eclair are my favourite.

DEB NORRIS

The best "donut holes"ever

William Heisel

My wife is a real cake aficionado. Taylors cakes are by far her favorites. She is thrilled whenever I come home with Taylors donut holes. (My wife is actually thin!)

angela groscost

The kids and I love this place. Awesome customer service and tasty treats! Recommend highly

Sherri Pritchard

Always have a great selection of pastries.

Gabriela Rodriguez

I bought a birthday cake here for a relative. It was a white cake with butter cream frosting and was not very good. The cakes at Costco are much better for less money.

Frank Owens

They used to have good donuts but the quality has gone very far down, in looks, taste, and smell. It’s as though the donut makers from Walmart and Meijer took the bakery over. All I can find are tasteless donuts made of cheap ingredients. Very disappointed.

Josh Banks

Delicious pastries!

Michaelle Thixton

Love Taylor's bakery! Their cakes and pastries never disappoint!

Charity Wimmer

Baklava yum, they have great bakery items, and must have more than one location, because I asked about a business card to get pricing on wedding cakes, but she said I'd have to call the other shop for that...other than that they had so many yummy goodies to choose from!

Kyle Bowmar

I got my wedding cake here and it was delicious and beautiful!

Jason Fagel

Donuts are fresh. Prices are great

Taconna Daniels

The birthday cakes i ordered was beautifully done.. and the red velvet cake was great...

Vashaun Holland

Fast with friendly service with a wide selection of treats.

mothersclub Unknown

Many wonderful items, friendly service, old fashioned family values...but my favorite thing by far is the ganache cake. OMG! Heaven on earth!

Linda Alich

I shop here almost weekly. Everything here is awesome. Staff is friendly and patient while I try to choose from all the wonderful baked goods

David Barker

Love their Eclairs. The closest that I can find that compares to the late Roslyn Bakery eclairs.

Vicki Waizenhofer

Love this bakery

Mo Wright

Really good sweets and top notch bagguettes! Reasonably priced baked goods...

Tom Parker

Just plain GREAT, NUFF SAID.

Maureen Thaw

Grandkids love the goods