Reviews of Sweet Bettys Bakery (Bakery)

5600 E Virginia St e, Evansville, IN 47715, United States

Average Rating:


We've got all the feddbacks of people who buy the services of Sweet Bettys Bakery (Bakery) around Indiana area.

Nowadays the firm receives a rating of 4.5 stars over 5 and the score has been based on 64 reviews.

You may have noticed that the average of ratings that it reaches is nearly the best one, and it's based on a very large number of scores, so we can say that the evaluation is quite credible. If people have bothered to rate when they are satisfied with the business, it works.

You know that we don't usually stop to give evaluations when these are correct and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Bakery.

Where is Sweet Bettys Bakery?

REVIEWS OF Sweet Bettys Bakery IN Indiana

Claire Peacock

Sugar cookies were yummy! This is the second time I've tried cupcakes and cookies here. Tastewise, they just aren't anything special. Cupcakes have a nice density one wants in a cake, jest not much flavor. The frosting is just ok, kind of strange in both flavor and texture. There "heaping" type cookies are ok. I can see how some would love them. A little too crumbly for me. The ladies that work there are very nice and helpful.

TJ Dau

We went in to ask about wedding options. They were very nice and walked us through the process. All the cupcakes and frosting tasted good and the price (for wedding) was good. I will definitely suggest them! It's even worth going in and seeing all the fun decorations all over the store!

Carolanne Lock

Our wedding cake was beautiful. It tasted amazing. Had some issues with my cake stand & they wanted me to sign a waiver saying I was liable if it fell. My other vendors for the wedding told me not to.. we figured out a different solution. Still thought the waiver thing was weird.

Ashley Taylor

Delicious. The cookies and baked goods are amazing. The shop is cute. The people are always very nice.

Shirley Hamilton

Darrin Jenkins

Lana Mays

A quaint place tucked away in a strip mall! It's decorated with vintage kitchen and household items. The cupcakes I got were very good and not overpriced. I will visit again!

Amy N Banet

Ashley Tubbs

Sweet Betty's has amazing cupcakes, cookies, buckeyes, etc.! Loved the 50's vibe and the assortment of eclectic items for viewing and for sale around the store.

Derrick Walker

Melissa Sloan

Charming little spot for a sweet pick me up!

Tay Renee

Great theme. Funny staff

Emily Hinds

This is a fun retro place where you can buy the artwork on the walls. The cupcakes are amazing. Moist and soft and the frosting is out of this world. They had many gormet flavor options but also your normal ones as well. They did have macroons also but I didn't see them before I had already ordered but they looked good. Definitely a cute place and we'll go back!

Tnea Turner

The customer service is amazing! However the cupcakes tasted like trash along with my son's first birthday cake though they were beautiful. Only 6 we're completely eaten out of 36. I had this cupcakes 2 years ago and thought them amazing and so I wanted them for my son's 1st birthday but it was a complete fail. I honestly wish I would have went to Walmart.

Kaylynn McCalister

Sweet Betty's did an amazing job with our wedding cake! It was beautiful and tasted great--we got many comments about how yummy the cake was! The Bettys are all so sweet and easy to work with, and the shop is lovely too!

Reyna Rodriguez

Everything is so yummy ! :)

Mallory Brummett

This place is absolutely AMAZING! customer service is FANTASTIC! Their prices are pricey. They do all kinds of cakes, treats, and they have several non food goodies. I pre ordered my daughter's cake, showed them a picture of what I wanted, and pick up my cake. They work with your schedule for pick up. They make sure you get exactly what you want.

Bridgette Howerton

The smash cake, cupcakes, and French macaroons for my daughter's first birthday party were a hit! So delicious and I highly recommend thos bakery for anyone who wants quality ingredients and quality specialty products.

Pamela Wilson

My daughter and I went to Sweet Betty Bakery......Omg

Tori Neiheisel

We used Sweet Bettys for our wedding and while the mini cupcakes, cheesecake bites and macaroons turned out OK (maybe 3.5 stars) the customer service left much to be desired. During the informal tasting we paid for, when I called to make a deposit and when I called to finalize my order and make payment they emphasized how busy they were and made me feel like a nuance. Definitely one of the few pain points in my wedding planning.

Hillary McCarty


Mara Lowery

Kyran Byrd

Great cupcakes

Rachel Howson

Ordered my grandson's smash cake for his 1st birthday from here. It was perfect! And their different flavored cupcakes are amazing. Their pricing is very fair and the staff are all so nice and friendly. Highly recommend them.

I did it woo

natalie horne

Andrea Paulnitz

Amazing staff, amazing cupcakes, and cute whimsical gifts

Carissa Bristoe

They made an awesome splatoon themed cake for my son’s 8th birthday it was amazing looking and delicious! Definitely would recommend!

Isabella Bertinelli

C R Essary

Really SWEET little place! Love the décor.

Abbie Smith

UPDATE: one of the owners called to talk about my concerns, and she was 100% genuine! There was zero confrontation, and she actually wanted to hear what her customer had to say. She talked about how they had switched providers and altered recipes, so hearing my honest feedback helped her! Very sweet girl! ------- The cake looked very good for what it was, but unfortunately it tasted awful. It was a chocolate cake with I assume buttercream, but the cake tasted like nothing and I was even told the icing was "weird" and "tasted like wax". We had gotten cupcakes a few days before, to try the place out-- not good either. I do not recommend, unless you are looking for something that ONLY looks good. Sorry Sweet Betty's.

E'Asia Thomas

Kayla Hammel

Cute shop, delicious cupcakes. Service is okay.

Senta Baker

Victoria Austin

Best bakery in the tristate! Wonderful staff, always super friendly. We've ordered a specialty cake the past 4 years for my daughter's birthday & it's not only been amazingly delicious, but amazingly executed! Masterpieces

kathy radwan

I ordered a 2 tier graduation cake for my son, in vanilla and banana and cant wait to see it! Their cakes are great! I've ordered 2 wedding cakes and 2 birthday cakes from them and always so beautiful and the taste is amazing :) Also got cupcakes and cookies cant say enough about how good they are. Will definitely go back! Also they are always friendly and helpful thank you

ZX10RFast Fast

Amazing staff cupcakes are wonderful i got the singer prince cupcake with his symbol on it very good and the homemade marshmallows are excellent i like shopping in the bakery when i am there the decor is amazing i like the jack and jane items they have

Marissa Price

Grant Johnson

Fabulous & the cookies alone are to die for!

Curtis Garrett

They do a great job with our cupcakes and cakes. Neat little family owned shop. Check it out if you have time. Delicious stuff.

Jessyka May

Liz Ertle

Delicious cupcakes, cute atmosphere and friendly staff.

Cyliciana Zanthe Crowe

Their buckeyes are to die for!!! And such great prices!

Andrew Huffman

I didn't go there

Kasey Burris

Lonnie Harter

Best place in town to satisfy your sweet tooth...

Scott Larock

I decided to try them out today. I got a few chocolate chip cookies and white chocolate pecan cookies. I did not find them very good at all and threw them away after trying one of each. I won't we going back.

Ambyr Brosmer

Very cozy, cute place to grab some cupcakes! Totally recommend.

Megan Mayberry

This little shop is so cute! I'm really glad I found them. The decor is so adorable, and their sweets are so tasty! My friend got a cupcake (fairly priced) and I got a few macaroons to try. They were so good!

Corinne Johnson

We surprised my mother-in-law with an custom cake for her 60th birthday. She orders from Spankys Pizza so much, they know here number and greet her by name when she calls. So we asked Sweet Bettys to make a cake that looked like one of their pizza boxes (we gave them one for reference). It came out so realistic, my mother-in-law was confused why we were presenting her with a pizza box with candles in it! She loved it and it tasted great! I was also pleasantly surprised to realize they used actual icing, not fondant so the whole thing was eatable. Sweet Betty's did an amazing job!

Dann Collins

Excellent. I would recommend to anyone.

Melanie Lutz

Made customized cookies for my daughter graduation. Not only were they adorable but were delicious

Doretha Wernicke

The cupcakes were very delicious.

Alison Sigman-Powell

More than a bakery! So much cute stuff to buy for gifts!

Amanda Murray

The baked goodies are amazing. The gifts are one of a kind.

Kate Tye

Fun and cute shop with very yummy cupcakes!

Tiffany Reed

Lauri Maynard

Love Sweet Betty's, so helpful, excellent baked goods!!!

Vicki Paulnitz

Best bakery in town!

kent berberich

Derek Smith

megan vickers

super cute Peep cookies!!! so delicious

robin todd


Business Hours of Sweet Bettys Bakery in Indiana



Sweet Bettys Bakery en Indiana
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Rise'n Roll Bakery & Deli
Rise'n Roll Bakery & Deli
Bakery - Indiana


Sweet Bettys Bakery
Sweet Bettys Bakery
Bakery - Indiana


MCL Restaurant & Bakery Arlington
MCL Restaurant & Bakery A...
Bakery - Indiana

American restaurant

Rise 'n Roll Bakery
Rise 'n Roll Bakery
Bakery - Indiana


Las Americas
Las Americas
Bakery - Indiana