Reviews of Proper Pastry (Bakery)

139 N Main St, Roanoke, IN 46783, United States

Average Rating:


We have the reviews of people who are using the products and services of Proper Pastry (Bakery) around Indiana area.

Currently this firm gets a score of 4.6 stars out of 5 and the score has been based on 19 reviews.

You must have seen that the average score it has is practically the best, and it's based on a high number of opinions, so we may conclude that the assessment is very credible. If there are many people who bothered to give their opinion when they've done well with the business, is that it works.

You know that we do not usually bother to place scores when they are good and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Bakery.

Where is Proper Pastry?

REVIEWS OF Proper Pastry IN Indiana

Kathleen Mastrangelo

This is a wonderful bakery! The gluten free birthday cake we ordered for our daughter was gorgeous and super tasty. Go visit, if just for the macaroons! Consider yourself lucky that Anna puts out anything at all to purchase as a walk in. Go early and go often.

Liz Martin

Delicious!! All the macaroon flavors were so tasty! We also had a cinnamon roll, brownie bomb, cinnamon sugar doughnut and a chocolate croissant. Everything was so very good! This was our first, but definitely not last trip!

cathy simon

Absolutely awesome! Can’t wait to go back!

Matthew Graves

Gluten free, dairy free almond flax bars are amazing. Macarons are perfection and unlike any that you will find in Northeast Indiana. Chef Anna's time in Europe and years in fine kitchens & bakeries show in each of her pastries and cakes.

Jason Grothaus

Excellent bread coffee and suites

Shay Nichols

I was so excited to try this place today. Google said they were open on Sundays and their website had zero information about times. I drove almost 30 minutes to try this place. Got here and they aren't open. Lost a star for website and another for not updating Google info.

Brandon Musick

Everything about that place is amazing and wonderful

Danny Sauer

Really good fruit pastry; above average cupcakes. Friendly service in a really cute, well-maintained downtown setting.

Wes Anderson

We used Proper Pastry for our wedding g reception and were extremely pleased. Anna was polite, professional, and punctual! Everything was just how we wanted for our wedding day. We of course had some unique, great flavored wedding cakes along with brownie bombs and macarons. Would definitely recommend Proper Pastry!

Brianna England

Proper Pastry made our wedding cake. Anna was wonderful to work with! Our tasting was so much fun, our cake was beautiful, delicious, and exactly what we wanted! 10/10 would recommend!

Joann Hart

Not a very wide selection of items but the pastries they do have are good. Cramped inside so best to get your dessert & coffee to go.

Jade Kelsey

The name says it all. You've never had an Almond Croissant until you've had one here.

Rosette Pine

David Reisig

jonathan walker

Amazing place--we are lucky to have someone of Anna's skill and care in the region. Her creations will redefine your idea of the word pastry!

Joe Hiner

Service was ok. Prices high.


Kevin Archambault

Michael Tome

Great little bakery shop that sells a plethora of tasty items and one of the only places around that sells fresh Macaroons..

Business Hours of Proper Pastry in Indiana



Proper Pastry en Indiana
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Linne's Bakery & Cafe
Linne's Bakery & Cafe
Bakery - Indiana


Vanilla Bean Bakery
Vanilla Bean Bakery
Bakery - Indiana


Heidelberg Haus
Heidelberg Haus
Bakery - Indiana

German restaurant

Long's Bakery
Long's Bakery
Bakery - Indiana


Over the Top Bakery Cafe
Over the Top Bakery Cafe
Bakery - Indiana