Reviews of New Haven Bakery (Bakery)

915 Lincoln Hwy, New Haven, IN 46774, United States

Average Rating:


We've got the feddbacks of real people who are consuming the products and services of New Haven Bakery (Bakery) in Indiana area.

At present this business gets a score of 4.7 over 5 and this rating is based on 60 reviews.

You may have noticed that its rating is almost the best one, and it's based on a very high number of scores, so we may say that the score is quite reliable. If people have bothered to give their opinion when they've done well with the business, is that it works.

You know that we do not usually bother to write opinions when these are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Bakery.

Where is New Haven Bakery?

REVIEWS OF New Haven Bakery IN Indiana

James Ringswald

I have nine kids... and anytime I need a little Popularity Boost... all I need to do is stop by the New Haven Bakery on my way home for a nice variety of everything they have... because... Everything They Have Is DELICIOUS!! The owner, Katie, and staff are AWESOME and always Super Friendly! Oh... and... I live in the Waynedale-Ossian area near another very popular bakery, but my kids and I all prefer the New Haven Bakery, Hands Down!

Tequila Freeman

The cakes are very good but thats it

Melinda Creek

amazing peoplr


The owner is very nice and everything is fresh

James Krueger

Love this place, great family owned bakery.

Bardus Plumbeus

The donuts are good, and the service staff is very friendly. They have cookies, and homemade pies on the menu as well. A tip for those trying this place: They start baking their batches at 11 PM ~ 3 AM, so the earlier you go, the fresher they'll be

Donald Overbay

Great service everytime

Juanita Knott

Mike Fox

Tom Mackin

The best caramel cinnamon rolls EVER!


Ordered our granddaughter's bday from NH Bakery and it was beautifully decorated and taste wonderful, very moist. Thanks again Katie!!

Will Hoo

CASH ONLY! They seem like a great shop, but they don't take credit card - it's cash only. I didn't have any cash on me, so I couldn't actually try a Donut.

Kyle Putt

Best donuts in town. Just remember your cash.

Amanda Geisler

Smells better than it taste

Charles Cuny

A little small-town bakery with great donuts. While passing through town, we stopped and bought a few donuts. We went down the street to eat them. They were so good, we went back and bought a dozen more "for the road." Every flavor I've had has been a winner.

Penny Russell

Always beautiful cakes and yummy cookies and doughnuts.staff is super friendly!!

Randy Wells

Roy Sorg

Delicious donuts and very friendly staff.

evan cannon

Good donuts

Dave Maroney

charles borkholder

Terry Fisher

Nothing fancy but the baked goods are really good, fresh and prices are reasonable. We visit a couple of times a month and have yet to be disappointed.

Kevin Hapner

MATT Green

Bonita Stevens

Every year New Haven Bakery has donated a sheet cake for our Hoosiers Feeding the hungry bow shoot and BBQ. Every year they outdo themselves. Thank you for your support.

jenny Shanebrook

If you want an Awesome cake, this is the BEST place to go. Katie, the owner, is Wonderful. Their is not a sweeter person than her. She puts her whole ❤️ into what she does. My husband knows to get me a "Katie Cake" every year for my birthday, and any month in between

Katie P

I would give them 0 stars if I could. We tried their cake which was OK. Thr lemon cake they gave us tasted old. We had set up a tasting and then after we called or stopped in over 5 times to try and get a quote for a wedding of over 300 people. They lost our business because they couldnt get back to us or be bothered to make official arrangements. They wasted my time. Luckily we found a great cake elsewhere.

Michelle Brandt

They offer a coffee bar also. Amazing cakes decorated to your specification. Cookies, donuts, pies...My favorite...Rolls. Better than the Hawaiin bread. There special rolls come in many sizes/shapes love the smaller buns for little sandwiches. Staff is always friendly and helpful!

David Johnston

Penny Doty

Mike Hamblin

Best doughnuts!!

Doug Dunakin

Nice little Bakery with a friendly waitress!!

Courtney Heddens

Amazing donuts! Also does custom cupcakes and cakes that look and taste amazing!

Anna Murphy

Made my daughter's baby shower cake. Always do a nice job

Jon Carlson

Best donuts ever!!!! The people that work there are the best!!!!!!

Margaret Cameron

Chris Smelser

Very nice service good donuts.

Mike Granning

Ron Oberley

Great people quality bakery


Great place to take the kids on a Saturday morning. Simple small town place.

Kyle Brown


Mike P

Great staff, great donuts and cakes

James Rorick

Joe Sarazen

Great bakery great Donuts great cakes and pies great service

Mark Holst

Just right for me. They're is a nice selection of donuts and rolls of you're into such things. Make mine a chocolate iced cake donut or two and a coffee. Coffee, like from a coffee pot.


matt lortie

Local favorite, Best price !awesome Donuts ! Best Cake around! Staff friendly great service

Dustin Keesbury

Chris Louagie

Neil Ehle

Shanoa Russell

GI Bro

Great place" the best doughnut in town.

Mark Franco

The place to be in New Haven

Stephanie Branning

Best place ever!! Everything is fantastic!!

Dan Golden

Homemade huge donuts and friendly!

Jonathan Reeves

Nice staff. Good donuts. Reasonable prices.

tony fornell

John Zeimet

Brett Freiburger

Love the donuts

Mary Hamilton

Good coffee

Business Hours of New Haven Bakery in Indiana



New Haven Bakery en Indiana
View Phone Number
View WebPage


Others also saw
Rene's Bakery Inc
Rene's Bakery Inc
Bakery - Indiana


Marilyn's Bakery
Marilyn's Bakery
Bakery - Indiana


Tim's Bakery
Tim's Bakery
Bakery - Indiana


Titus Bakery
Titus Bakery
Bakery - Indiana


Sheila's Bakery Unlimited
Sheila's Bakery Unlimited
Bakery - Indiana