Reviews of The Sweet Spot Bakery Cafe (Bakery)

Joshua Kratzberg

Amazing baked delicacies! The staff is always amazing and any custom orders we have placed have always been spot on. Fantastic bakery in the heart of Caldwell.

Scott Schwab

The Sweet Spot Bakery nailed it. I wanted to try a couple of different items, so I had the Leprechaun treat, a piece of Marionberry Pie, and a cookie. All were amazing and probably the best place I have been in the area. The customer service was great, and I highly recommend going there.

Regina Craven Reiter

We enjoy coming to this spot. The place looks wonderful with the new look and I can't to mention the sweets are the best. Thank you girls

DeeJae Taylor

The women who work there are very sweet & the treats are delicious!

Damon Waldron

Great local bakery you can have your treat there or take it home. The staff are awesome and friendly always feel welcomed when I visit.

josh magill

This place is awesome!!!

Jake Theo Peterson

We contacted Sweet Spot through our wedding planner for our "pie table" on the big day. We ordered 90 pies - 30 heart-shaped hand pies, 30 pies baked inside mason jars, and 30 pie pops in assorted flavours. Wow! These made for a striking display next to the naked wedding cake. The taste was incredible and we received so many compliments from wedding guests. Highly recommended!!!

Mar Housley

Yummy, good lunch!

Bill Gardunia

The prices were too high and the product we bought wasn't that good. I won't go back

Aysia Magill

This place is hands down the best in the treasure valley! If you're looking for homemade, custom, and quality work with exceptional taste, this bakery is for you! They are highly demanded, so call in advance to place your order. Everything is delicious! Every year we order custom bithday cakes for my three children, along with so many other treats throughout the year! They also have a few take and bake items that are great for a new mother, sick loved one or just to make life a little easier. Worth the drive from anywhere.♡

Taunra Petersen

Such a fun place to stop and eat! Great food and a fun atmosphere

Daniel Kendall

Fantastic sweets, and delicious sandwiches.

Jordan Cross

These guys are absolutely awesome!!! Their sweets hit the spot every time! They also did our wedding cake and it was perfect! Matched the theme and tasted amazing!! Cant thank them enough.

Natalee Smith

Kept seeing this bakery pop up on my FB page and saw all the wonderful goodies, so I had to come and try them out. Let me just say, I was not disappointed!! Great selection, amazing desserts, and wonderful people. We'll be going back on Saturday to stock up for Easter Sunday. If you love bakery's like I do...you're going to love this place!!! Highly recommended!!

Stephanie Afamasaga

TAYLOR MORRIS, I am a proud Employee of SWEET SPOT BAKERY. The response I am about to provide is a factual and non-bias statement. I happened to be the the other associate communicating and observing the details with taking your order on this day. I was paying very close attention due to the fact that I am fairly new, and training. Upon being hired, it was expressed to me how important it is to get details, likes, and dislikes when taking an order for a semi custom or custom cake. One of the most important strong suites that Sweet Spot Bakery provides to the community is executing a customer cake order to the very best of their ability. They take great pride in knowing that their product, and creations provide the perfect aesthetic to any life celebration and day. While observing your questions, wants and needs for your sons 1st Birthday. You explained it was a monster theme. Penny showed you an example of a previous cake done. It was greens, blues, and you loved it. You explained that the theme was monster GOOGLY EYES. As Penny asked for any more details? You and your Mother both said, “ we’re not picky”... You also made the statement that, you trust our opinion and work, as long as it had “GOOGLY EYES”.. With those details given, the Birthday cake was the blues and greens with GOOGLY EYES... similar to the one you loved from our photos. The smash cake was done orange to give variation in some bright color, and extra fun for your sons birthday. The horn that took extra time, and creative work was a little something to make this little monster cute. I’m sorry you were not happy about the stabilizing stick to hold the horn secure. Most know that these are needed to hold upright fondant on custom cakes. Even without this stabilizer, the horn could potentially poke an eye and injure it. If you intend smashing your 1 year olds face, I would recommend removing it either way. This is common parenting advice from one mother to another. It really is not about the stabilizer stick. I am also very sorry about the buttercream getting touched when being boxed. I am very sorry we had to “fix” it for you. Last but not least, I am very sorry that your statements, “ I am not picky” and “we trust your opinion” resulted in an adorable “ORANGE “ Monster smash cake with a horn that had a lot of love and creative effort applied into it. A big part of it was that horn she added to make it extra cute. Words of advice to you Taylor, “communication is key” in any situation. Especially with “expectations”... I am so sorry you are not going to return. I agree that Walmart Bakery will be a better choice for you. Your attempt to imply that Sweet Spot Bakery is incompetent, and unprofessional, really shows how much bliss ignorance holds. Good luck with your future cake orders! Proud Employee of SWEET SPOT BAKERY

Audrey Dickson

We love going to this bakery!

iris mead

My husband is addicted !

Lisa Gray

I picked up my grandsons 1st birthday cake recently, this is the small cake they call a "smash cake". It was a themed cake which matched his birthday decorations. It is one of the plainest, ugliest and "unspecial" cakes I have ever seen from a specialty bakery. It breaks my heart that my daughter paid over $50 for something that looks like it came from Walmart for $8.50. If the bakery was too busy to create something special then either they should have charged less, or turned down the order.

Shannon Stohr

OMG this place is AMAZING. Friendly Lady at the counter and the Sweets are SOOO good. Got a Eclair and Apple Pocket thing and she gave us a Macaroon .. OMG i'm in heaven! Definitely gong back

Robert Loper

High quality, well made goods. Worth every penny.

Patricia Patterson

They have done amazing by us both times we ordered from them. Love their cakes and the macaroon cookies!!

Donna Lam

The sticky buns are amazing!

Alyssa Millen

The food truck was mediocre (have not been to the bakery). But the guy was friendly and $7 isn't bad.

Sharon Grant

Great Pot Pie!

Bryan Bowermaster

They were so nice to allow for such a high hospitality to Gretchen while she was in town. Excellent food too.

Colette Scheideler

Consistently Delicious Treats!

Sharon Lonsberry

I got cupcakes for my granddaughters 16th birthday party, alice and wonderland themed and got cupcakes with a rose shaped frosting instead i got a moutain of frosting that tasted like dye and looked nothing like a rose, i was very disappointed and very mad, because i paid a lot of money that i work hard for....and i wish i could give 0 stars.....i will not be coming back and i will never recommend them to anyone

Taylor Morris

Ordered some Monster themed cakes for my sons 1st birthday, paid $75 . They were ready to pick up on time but when I saw them, one was the wrong color . Asked them to re-do the one, which they did, and they had it ready for me to pick up the next day .The worker smeared the writing at the base of the cake while loading it into the box, but fixed it for me. Went and picked up the second cake, the smaller smash cake for my 1 year old son, again, the same person managed to swipe her finger through the textured frosting while loading the cake into the box. She didnt bother securing the cake in the box, so it slid around in the box on the drive home. Had a feeling that the fondant horn on top of the baby smash cake was secured with a stick of some sort, and boy was I right. Through the center of the cake was a 2 1/2inch plastic stick, remember, this is a smash cake for an infant, and they KNEW that . How would you feel if you didnt check your cake and your child smashed their face into a super hard rod??? I am NOT a happy mama .Will NOT be going back.

Kamelia Basir-Rodriguez

The ladies are always accommodating and very open on suggestions and budgets. I've gone to them every time for my kids' birthdays and all I would do is show them a picture for our theme and they rocked it from Japanese cherry blossoms to a How To Train Your Dragons 2 cake! Not only do they look unbelievable they taste delicious and my girls always shriek from excitement when they see their creations. Until they become crazy famous, they'll definitely be my go-to bakery.

Wolf Vlogs Wolfie

Really great service

Brian Eilers

Stopped in yesterday for the first time. I purchased a dozen cinnamon rolls and a few other items. I have to say, I was very satisfied with the quality of each item. Best rolls I've had in years. Everyone of my employees really enjoyed them as well and wanted to know where they came from.

Frank Creasey

Great atmosphere and great sweets. Customer service is wonderful.

K Thomas

Lovely little bakery and cafe. Small selection but what is there is good. Today we had both types of cinnamon rolls (original and raspberry) and a bacon and cheese turnover. Last visit we had raspberry bars and a few cookies. So far all our choices have been delicious.

Jason Sevy

Needed 150 cupcakes for a open house. They turned into the hit of the party. Could have not been better!

Shellie

Always fresh, always good!!!!!

Harley Ayala

The service was weak

Sharon Riker

I so enjoy the treats and the staff are just amazing. Highly recommend a visit to the Sweet Spot Bakery.

Amy Beckner

Stopped in about a month ago. It was towards the end of the day, so selection was small. Cookies were ok. Tarts needed more flavor. Staff was friendly.

Joey Delgado

If I were on death row ordering my last meal, their macaroons would be the first thing I would ask for. As a world traveled food-y they are by far one of the best bakery I've ever been too. The macaroons are to die for, but everything is exceptional including the staff.