Reviews of Sweet Valley Cookie Co (Bakery)

Logan Martin

Good cookies but also fairly pricey.

Roy Kimball

Cool little place to tame your sweet-tooth. They not only have cookies... you can also find chocolate, ice cream, and a few quirky gag gifts. Cookies are big and tasty, but the Brookies (a brownie topped with a chocolate chip cookie) are a must. Free parking in the city lot next door. Pleasant staff and happy to accept volume orders.

Lauren Johnson

We used Sweet Valley Cookies as party favors for our sons 1st birthday - 12 lemon burst and 12 ginger. BOTH cookies are delicious - I cannot tell you how many people from the party have shared with me how delicious the cookies are. I am so happy I got to share some of my favorite treats in Eagle with my friends. Thanks SVC Co!

Jen Knight

Such a great place, Delish every time

Kandi V.

From the moment you walk into the shop the smell of heaven infects your nasal passage.. never mind the taste .... To quote Peter Griffin.. Oh my God Lois, these sweet valley cookies, oh my God

Peasley C

Perfection in the art of baking giant cookies, in a cute little house that smells delightful and also has a toy shop. What’s not to like ?

Stephanie Butterfield

We arrived just a few minutes before closing on A Saturday afternoon, but the lady was very patient and nice. We tried 3 different varieties of cookie and all 3 were am amazing. The shop was cute, clean and smelled heavenly. It was a lovely treat.

John Kehr

This is a must try.. And by that I mean the cookie and ice cream.

Dana Fillmore

Great tasting cookies, charming little store.

April Nappi Ward

I am so grateful to be able to purchase delicious gluten free cookies for my son and I. Especially since Jake's Place closed, we've missed having a place we can go for a special treat. Now, we go to Sweet Valley Cookie Co.! The cookies are delicious and we've never had any issues with a gluten reaction. The staff are also knowledgeable and helpful.

Michael Hirst

Very friendly people and delicious cookies!! Plus a fun atmosphere.

Julie Sirhall

Cookies so wonderful Grandma buys them and says they are hers!

rhonda aliah

Friendly staff and great cookies!

Anna S.

Amazing gift shop. The chocolate chip cookie was so/so I won't buy another one. The brookie was okay but not great and not worth $3. I loved the chocolate crinkle cookie because it reminded me of cocoa puffs somehow. The tiny milk was on sale since the store was doing a buy 2 cookies and a drink for $4.50 without tax. Which means the cookies were not on sale since they are normally $2 a piece. The milk is normally $1 so it was 1/2 off which is good because I would never be willing to pay full price for it.

Earl Fish

This place is the best! It is underrated and not well known but it has a large variety of cookies and treats and the service is local and very kind.

Meagan Walker

Always smells great, and has the nicest staff

Rich Fennelle

Poor service... turtles I could get at Wal-Mart

Laurissa Youngblood

I truly believe Sweet Valley Cookie Co has the best sugar cookie in the Treasure Valley! Not to mention Heidi has designed, and executed beautifully, themed cookies for my daughter’s 1st and 2nd birthday parties. Repeat customer over here and it’s going to stay that way! I highly recommend SVCC for all your [party] cookie needs. Thank you Heidi and staff, we will see you again when we bring in 3 (but probably sooner, like we could stay away that long)!!

Bill Taylor

Just had an excellent lunch at SVCC. Their soup bowls are great!

Phillip Stafford

My wife said this was the best cookie she has ever had.

Delena Vail

Loved it!

Christen Rowles

I like this place, but the cookies aren't as good as they cost. They've added a lot of cool new stuff though.

Calvin Lindemann

Excellent cookies and great allergy accommodations.

Patricia Jasso

Delicious sweets

Lacy Sereduk

Smells delicious as soon as you get close to the door. It's very clean, has a nice vibe, and there's a lot to look at. I got a salt caramel that was made in Weiser and a salt caramel made in the shop. The one made in the shop was way better as far as the texture of the caramel, flavor, and the chocolate was better. The one from Weiser had that weird bitterness to the chocolate that you get from when the chocolate is cheaper or old. The ginger cookie I bought was soft to chew and sturdy enough to hold. I prefer a lot more ginger-y flavor but it went great with my coffee.

Stephen D

The Brookie is absolutely amazing!!! Worth the trip from wherever you live!!!!

Yvette Wilde

i came in expecting normal cookies, but these are exceptional. i tried chocolate chip and the lemon cookie, and cant wait to go back to try the snickerdoodle and blondie. not going to be good for my waistline but will be well worth it.

Kevin Headings

Awesome cookies!

Heidi Tilby

The very best cookies!

Cody Young

Tasty treats and funny little accessories