Reviews of Evening Rise Bread Co (Bakery)

303 Sunset St, McCall, ID 83638, United States

Average Rating:


We've got the opinions of real people like you who purchase the products of Evening Rise Bread Co (Bakery) in the area close to Idaho.

Right now this business has a score of 4.4 over 5 and that score is based on 49 reviews.

As you can read, the average score it has is really good, and it is founded on a very high number of scores, so we can say that the valuation is quite faithful. If there are many people who bothered to give their opinion when they are pleased with the business, is that it works.

You know that we do not usually stop to set scores when these are good and we usually do it only if we have had a problem or issue...

This Bakery belongs to the category of Bakery.

Where is Evening Rise Bread Co?

REVIEWS OF Evening Rise Bread Co IN Idaho

Mary Ann Payne

Great food! Nice clean restaurant.

Kyle Alan

Delicious sandwich

Margaret Prescott

Excellent sandwiches and microbrews! Friendly service

Jason Lloyd

I'm totally conflicted about this place. Their sandwiches and breads are excellent. The service, however, leaves a lot to be desired. If you've ever seen the Seinfeld episode "The Soup Nazi", that would perfectly describe this place. The food is great, but there is one employee, possibly the owner, who is always in a bad mood and responds curtly to any inquiry. If you ask, "What's on the New Yorker sandwich, we've had that here before and loved it", he retorts, "that's Friday's special!", and nothing more. Guess you can't build your own New Yorker on any other day than Friday? Let's say you want to know "do you have sourdough bread today?", he sharply bites back with "all our breads are written on the wall!" I am absolutely convinced if I ask one more question the verdict will be, "No sandwich for you!" The guy even has the soup Nazi's mustache. While I really enjoy the food at this place and they have a quality product that absolutely deserves five stars, I have to deduct for their service (and probably should deduct more than just one star). If you are in town and don't have to deal with this guy on a regular basis, it's worth the hassle and almost amusing to see how much this guy can't stand other people. He actually shut down and stopped serving sandwiches today at 1:30, even though they are open till 5, and I think it was because he got frustrated with a few customers. I was glad we had already gotten our food, and we happily ate at the outside table as we saw droves of customers turning away saying, "I guess they stopped making sandwiches" in absolute confusion.

Mary Pasley

Delicious sandwiches and great bread! Worth the wait!

Chris Schlieper

I try to buy bread here every week, they have the best fresh baked bread I have ever tasted. My wife laughs at me because I always plan a special day to go into town just to get their bread. I highly recommend their baked bread.

Oleksandr Filipchuk

Don Chambers

This place is the bomb! Great sandwiches,it’s kind one of those what ever you want,they make it kind of sandwich place! Service is great the staff acts kinda gruff but that’s the atmosphere

ALberto Buttler

This place is the best sandwich joint on this earth. Every year when I am back I make it a mission to step foot on these hallowed grounds. Everyone that is complaining about the service can take a hike. The staff could scold me publicly and I would still come back. They aren't sandwiches rather they are art.

Gavin Baker

Jameson Dunn

Bread and sandwiches were great!

Taylor King

Gus Guzman

Absolutely incredible. Half the reason we come to mccall is these sandwiches. From the bread, to the meats, to the fix ins, everything is high quality and fresh, and you know it from the first bite to the last.

Holly Jewell

I love this place! Great sandwiches, wide variety of sodas, yummy homemade cookies. But the star is the bread!!! And the bagels! And the scones! Did I mention the bread is amazing? It is so AMAZING! Expect a short wait, but it's so worth it! Get there early when they open to get the best selections of fresh bread.

Yuri Davydov

Gerry G

Great sandwiches, and definitely oversized, so bring a good appetite.

Ashley Butters

The absolute best in McCall!

John Stevens

Food is always fresh, great, and very generous portions. Service can be sweet or ornery, depending on the day. Have your order ready when it is your turn!

Corbin Hall

First rate bread and deli sandwiches.

Hunter Baum

Would be 5 stars....If you could count on the place being open! Always a crapshoot whether they will be open or not, but when they are, they serve the best sandwiches in town.

Derek's Swanderr

Food is good, but customer service sucks.

Catherine Gowans

Best sandwiches in Idaho! We had a relatively large group, especially for a Winter Carnival Saturday and we expected to wait an hour or more for a meal. We were pleasantly surprised when we had our food within 15 minutes! The staff are quick and efficient but so friendly! And the sandwiches are phenomenal! Piled high with delicious meats and toppings, super soft yummy bread. Specialty soft drinks and kettle chips make this the perfect lunch! Thank you for your service and hospitality! ~~Western Riding Club Royalty (and their families) =D

Jacqueline Ibarra

Jeff Bulkley

Good food! Crappy attitude from employees.

Laszlo Bedegi

Most relaxing. ..most friendly. ...most of all most delicious sandwiches in McCall for the best price anywhere. ...even music and laughter is shared among friends in our Community. ..thank you

Delora Allen

Have loved Evening Rise from their very beginnings, stop back in whenever I get to McCall

Laurel Adams

Had a GREAT sandwich there yesterday .. bread with Kalamata olives! Who knew? Prosciutto, veggies, generous portions. My half sandwich filled me UP - I couldn't quite finish it! Will definitely go back.

Jade Rogers

I love the Evening Rise, it has some of the best bread around every time i'm up there I go and buy some great bread. Once I was choosing between two kinds and they gave me the one I payed for plus the other one I wanted. If you are ever in McCall make sure to stop by. : )

April Whitney

Fantastic artisan bakery with the best sandwiches in town. Yum!

Kamron Nay

Sandwiches are to die for. Sadly they have wildly inconsistent hours. Last three times we tried to go, they were closed even though the official sign AND the temporary sign said they were open. Oh well. Went to staxs instead.

Austin Shotwell

Hailee Bulkley

The food is great but the customer service is awful.

Jerri Woodworth

Julie Price

Terry Reynolds

Amazing sandwiches!!

Donna-Christine McGuire

Best sandwiches ever, anywhere!!!! Do not pass through McCall without stopping or you’ll live a life of regret!

clayton white

Jason Bahruth

SMH Contact

While the bread and sandwiches are great, the guys who work here are so rude I honestly can't stand to go here anymore. For example, I ordered a sandwich but had to wait a long time while they made sandwiches for folks (I assume friends/regulars) who came in and ordered AFTER me. They are also never actually open during their posted hours. If you can stand being treated like garbage, this is a great place to grab lunch, but I can't do it anymore.

Tric Sechler

Work friendly atmosphere, great sandwiches. Excellent

Isaac Page

Great sandwiches, good bread, but the customer service and wait times are complete crap.

Kelly Martin

Definitely the best sandwich place in town...amazing bread and other fixings! And the sandwiches are huge! You get your money's worth! Don't forget to get the caramel and nut cookie, best I've ever had! Love this local favorite!


Pro Power Performance, Inc.

This place is the bomb. If you haven't been, you simply must go! The bread is fabulous (haven't had their sandwiches yet but they look amazing!). You should probably buy several different loaves because how could you possibly choose just one. We had their cinnamon raisin, jalapeno cheddar and the walnut/blue cheese wheat. All are absolutely fantastic. Thank you Corey for the wonderful bread. And for the record: one CAN live on bread alone!

Dawna Hein

Food was great! Love the homemade breads and the variety of sodas. Also liked that they thanked us as we left even though they were really busy. We'll be back for sure!

Greg G

One of the best sandwiches I have had in my life and I'm not even exaggerating. Will be a must stop for every visit to Mccall here on out!

Isaac Williamson

JR Robinson

The hours say open 11-4 Tuesday thru Saturday. But here it is noon on Wednesday and they are closed. Ive been trying to eat here for the last 2 weeks and they are never open! The sandwiches are amazing but service is terrible.

Tom O'Reilly

Great food. Staff can be a bit short with customers when they are busy.

Business Hours of Evening Rise Bread Co in Idaho



Evening Rise Bread Co en Idaho
View Phone Number
View WebPage

Others also saw
Franz Bakery Outlet
Franz Bakery Outlet
Bakery - Idaho


Amaru Confections
Amaru Confections
Bakery - Idaho


La Vanilla Bean
La Vanilla Bean
Bakery - Idaho


Vagabond Bakery Boise
Vagabond Bakery Boise
Bakery - Idaho

Cake shop

Sweet Valley Cookie Co
Sweet Valley Cookie Co
Bakery - Idaho

Cookie shop