Reviews of Floribbean Flo's (Bakery)

Andy Welihozkiy

Stop your searching - This is THE BEST Key Lime Pie in Florida hands down! A true gem of Sarasota. You owe yourself to give them a try.

Aaron

The best real Key lime pie in Florida! It’s a must when visiting Sarasota! They use actual key limes unlike most other places and it makes a world of difference! The honey bell orange cake is also out of this world!

Stephen Conover

If there's a better key lime pie than this one, I haven't found it yet. And honestly? After tasting this pie, you just may stop looking too!

Jeff Klosner

Best key lime pie I’ve ever had. The passion fruit pie was amazing as well.

Joanne Williscroft

While writing this I am enjoying a piece of Orange cake glazed with a burbon liquor. It is phenomenal! had their Key lime pie which is the best I've had. Charming small bakery with personal touch service and the best baked goods and chocolates. They also serve small lunches.

Shariq Khan

Best pie ever

Tim T

Great key lime pie! Also enjoyed the frozen key lime on a stick and the orange creamsicle pie

Will Harbauer

This place seems like it is the best kept secret in Sarasota. I was fortunate to have a co-worker vacation here and tell me that I had to check them out and to get a Key Lime pie. My wife and I walked in for the first time yesterday and we were blown away by the most incredible smell of baked goods. While they had a selection of pies and treats, we ordered a whole Key Lime pie. It's just like homemade! We are trying to savour it as long as possible!

Caleb Kmeicik

Best key lime pie arround

Logan

Close your eyes and imagine the perfect key lime pie. You get that pie here.

Barbara Simari

4.50 dollars for a microscopic piece of cake. A robbery. They had two cakes only and didn't look attractive.

Tim Kaye

Best key lime pie around!

Andy Kohn

Great key lime and passion fruit pies. Friendly owners

Kyle Hauser

We recently had a family gathering in Sarasota. I’d had a Floribbean Flo’s key lime pie before and, thinking it was the beatbox aid ever had, picked up two for the family. All 15 tasters gave Flo a unanimous 5 star rating. Make sure you stop for one of these pies! They are incredible!!

Trisha Wightman

I have been searching for authentic keylime pie along the coast and I FOUND IT! I walked in and the owner immediately gave my husband and I a sample of not only the keylime, but also the bananas foster!!! Oh my gosh ... both SIMPLY TO DIE FOR! We bought both. The owner even gave us ice packs for our drive home. Of course we then had to buy a cooler ... ha. Trust me, it is worth the trip. A perfect little mom and pop shop filled with darling gift items, desserts, candy, and savory food items! We'll done Flo!

Brittany Mitchell

I don't do very many reviews but you must stop at this little gem of a place at Siesta Key!!! Their Chocolate covered frozen keylime pie on a stick is the best dessert I've EVER HAD!!!....along with all of their awesome many varieties of homemade cookies & pies! 3rd time to Siesta Key and just found out from a friend that this place was here. Such a sweet couple that runs this place. Please make it a point to go out of your way to stop by here spend your money to keep them in business!

Chevy Mathews

Great food and service! The pulled pork is amazing!! And the key lime pie is definitely the best I’ve had north of key west!

Hunter Andre

These guys do a great job for me every time I need to send a gift to a family member or business associate. Thank you so much for everything.

Robb Brugh

Key Lime pie is the bomb!!!

martin noakes

Floribbean Flo's has become as much of an annual family vacation tradition as going to Siesta Key Beach. Just when I thought it wasn't possible to improve on their Key Lime Pie perfection, they took a slice, coated it in delicious dark chocolate and put it on a popsicle stick - amazing - can't wait to have another!!

Gwen Anderson

The BEST key lime pie I've ever tasted. If her sandwiches and other baked goods are anything like her key lime pie.... A hidden gem of a tropical bakery and gift shop.

Laura Hagler

The lemon beach pie is fantastic. We have had it both times we came down in the last year since finding the store. We also got some cute gifts for friends. I am looking forward to trying some of the other flavors.

Dennis McGraw

Excellent key lime pie

Zach Picciano

Best key lime pie in the area hands down

James Jennings-Wyckoff

This place has so many 5 star ratings for a reason. Their pies are fantastic and the other confections are very good and full of the flavors you'd expect

Alisa De Los Reyes

The best key lime pie ever!!!

Adam Poll

All agreed it was the best key lime pie they’d had, hopefully I’ll have time to try some other treats before heading home.

Krista Pizzurro

Why go to Publix when you can go here? Try anything and you won't be disappointed. The Passion fruit pie is an explosion of flavor!

Liz Schwab

My husband researched the best key lime pie near Siesta Key for my birthday dessert, and Flo’s did not disappoint! From the graham cracker crust to the tart but sweet topping, every bite was divine. It was so good, we went back to get a second pie!

jason hartley

Pies, cookies, and great food.

Donna Woolf

We vacation yearly in Siesta Key. We are sure to empty out our cooler so we can take Flo’s Key Lime Pies on the road. Flo’s pies are our absolute favorite. See you next year, again.

Monica Galfre

Amazing consistent quality! Their orange type cake was like fluffy air with just a beautiful well balanced hint of citrus.Highly recommended!

Jeremy Guenet

Best key lime pie! I didn’t have much time to thoroughly review the other day, but polishing off the last sliver this morning reminded me just how great this pie was. Please Please Please - Go to Flo’s and get a pie (or 6)! You won’t be disappointed. I’ve tried several when here on vacation and none come close. Not too sweet makes these the best.

bluethoth13

Flo and her husband make the best Key Lime Pie in Sarasota! You haven't had proper Key Lime Pie if you haven't had Flo's!

Melissa Bowes

A bit on the expensive side, but delicious! The truffles are amazing and the key lime was amazing.

Kyle Kaufman

Flo and her husband work absolute wonders with their key lime pie. My girlfriend and I have never had a better dessert in our lives. For all siesta key sunbathers please make stopping at Flo's the very first thing you do on your trip! One piece per night keeps your soul young and the rooster cawwing in the morning! Seriously, we challenge you to only eat one piece per night - the KLP is out of this world! Thanks the Flo's!

Louis Colantuono

Floribbean Flo’s makes THE BEST pies in Sarasota! The coconut cream, key lime and banana fosters are favorites.

Todd Smith

What an awesome place !!! Get the key lime pie ( you will ). You will be missing out on true treats. Meaning the other pies that are available. Sure having the key lime has health benefits, like preventing scurvy. But passion fruit will definitely turn any frown upside down.

Ray Donnelly

Having lived in Florida nearly all my life, I've tried key lime pies up and down the Keys and up to the Panhandle. Flo's is the real deal. Authentic with fresh key limes. Near Sarasota, don't hesitate....run to Flo's and sample a bite of Florida heaven!

Windy Winkle

Yum!!!!!! I was in search of the BEST Key Lime pie ! It's my business partners birthday and I knew I needed to find the best of the best. I started my search and found many 5 star reviews for Floribbean Flo's and as luck had it , they were just down the street from the office. Bonus!!! I bought a Key Lime pie and a nice Quiche for her Birthday surprise and they were both out of this world delicious. Whats better is I found that they also ship there delicious deserts where ever UPS goes. We are new fans for sure and just around the corner :) Yay!! Try it ! You won't be disappointed :):)

Leigh Collins

BEST EVER Key lime pie! And the owners are even better than the pie!

Julia Fisher

We came to Floribbean Flo’s after hearing it is the best Key Lime pie around. We bought a peanut butter pie as well as the key lime and both were so delicious! We came back to buy another key lime to bring to family and I also bought some cute ornaments and gift items. Jim and Nancy are both so lovely, it really was a pleasure to shop here :)

RonLinda Conti

We are new to Sarasota but Key Lime pie is iconic in Florida - and there are a lot of really marginal choices. The one at Floribbean Flo's, however, is so superior that we just don't bother trying it anywhere else. Don't know about the other pies...we only buy the Key Lime one! We called ahead because we were not going to get there before it closed and they willingly stayed open an extra 10 minutes for our arrival!

Kelly V

Rated the best Key Lime Pie in FL, this place did not disappoint. Flo is very sweet. You can tell she puts a lot of love in her pies. They taste fresh and the pie survived a day of shopping (tilted on its side) unscathed. Advice: If you like your pie more tart than sweet, buy 2 days before serving. Flo's is a easily missed small building with a bright pink facade.

george brewster

If I didn't visit Flo's I wouldn't know what real Key Lime Pie was. I've been going to Sarasota sine 1995 and only read about them about 5 or so years ago. I was there last week and ordered 2 pies. Needless to say I finished them in a week (i even had some for breakfast). This is be the only Key Lime pie I eat when I visit and hopefully when I retire to Sarasota

Larry Emery

Best key lime pie.

clark951

googled best key lime pie and came up with floribbean flo's which just happened to be like one block from where we were staying. great pie, even my mother in law was impressed and she thought she had already found the best. we had done a taste test several years ago but this was the best

Andrew Dare

The best key lime pie on earth.

Alex A'Hearn

BEST KEY LIME PIE YOU WILL EVER HAVE. GUARANTEED!!!!!

erika anderson

Spend every 4th of July in Sarasota and Flo's is one of our first stops. Best key lime pie ever. And the other pies are fabulous too!

Melinda Citro

Wowza good pie.

Paul P

This is absolutely the best key lime pie in the world! You owe it to yourself to visit this little bakery on Tamiami Trail

Janice Agro

The most amazing key lime pie in the world

Krystle McGowen

The best place to get everything Key Lime and unique gifts.

The Truth

I unfortunately have not been to your store, but after reading about your bakery online while I was visiting Sarasota, I made a note to try it out the next time I was in town. A family member remembered I mentioned your bakery, and brought me 2 chocolate covered frozen keylime pie slices all the way to Atlanta. They were amazing - I don't know if I can have keylime pie any other way now. Looking forward to trying your other items.

Joe Martin

Flo knows keylime!

Janet Hayes

I have lived in Florida most of my life and these Keylime pies are by far the best I've ever had! Whenever I have company in town a pie from Floribbean Flo's is a must!

Lori Hertenstein

We vacation in Sarasota frequently from Ohio and Floribbean Flo’s is our first stop. The Key Lime Pie is Phenomenal!!!! The Friendly service... makes us feel like family. I hope that anyone reading this takes a moment to stop in.. buy a Key Lime Pie and enjoy the same wonderful treat. It won’t disappoint! Thanks Flo for being there each year to make our vacation an even bigger treat!

Marla Perez

best key lime pie eveeeeer! you definitely have to try it.

Dan Gordon

As I walked thru the door, just a few minutes before closing, the owner greeted me with a 'This looks like a man on a mission!' statement..how right he was. I was looking for the best key lime pie in Sarasota, and i feel like the mission was definitely fulfilled! Great job!! Dan from Atlanta

Misty Stillion

The BEST key lime pie anywhere is at Flo's!!! I have tried a lot of key lime pie expecting it to have that perfect blend of tart and sweet like the very first time I tried it in Key West. Nothing came close. Then I found this gem called Foribbean Flo's and found theirs is the BEST key lime pie you can get anywhere! We’ve been coming here for the last several years and the quality and service is above par every time. It's my special treat everytime we vacation here. So much so that we get a second one later in the week because my husband and I love it so much. If you want authentic, homemade, quality, key lime pie look no further than Flo’s. Even if you don’t think you like key lime pie, you may have not tried the real deal - try it at Flo’s. You will love it! BEST KEY LIME PIE EVER!!! (Note: I don’t typically write reviews, but Flo’s is easily worth my time)

Jason Vest

Key Lime Pie, Passionfruit Pie, Peanut Butter Chocolate, everything we have tried is outstanding. We have to stop by this place every time we come to Florida.

chelsea ciomei

This is by far the BEST key lime pie I have ever tasted. The owner is the nicest lady, the overall expierince at this bakery was amazing.

Joan B

The passion fruit pie is simply delicious! Every time I visit my sister here I always have to take several of them back home for my bridge friends. Have been doing this for a couple of years now. We all love this pie!!

Ian Snyder

Absolutely amazing. Try the passion fruit or key key lime pie!! If you aren't a pie person the orange rum cake is amazing too. It's all so good and wonderful customer service!

Marieke Haster

We found this amazing little shop, bakery via google. The reviews made us stop to get the key lime pie on a very rainy day. The owners are so lovely, and we could geel their passion for their products. Thank you for taking the time toch talk to us making buying this pie such a wonderfull experience! When taking the first bite of this pie it was just amazing! If you want a great pie stop here to get one!!

David Bielby

Don't miss this gem. Wonderful little bakery with my favorite key lime pie in all of Florida! It's hard to find the drive way off Tamiami Trail but it's worth the effort!

Chris Albright

Wow! Fantastic pies!!! We ordered three pies for Thanksgiving and they were all delicious. Pumpkin pie with pecans on top. Key lime pie with juice from actual key limes (the family favorite). And their Apple pie (with a dollop of vanilla ice cream) was beyond description. This family-owned boutique bakery is a real gem.

Mike R

People. The reviews on Google are correct. The pies are scrumptious! We found this place after reading they have a delicious key lime pie. Jims wife gave us some samples of the lemon, key lime and passion fruit. We took two pies home for the family. Every one loved the pies.

Michael Iafigliola

Best key lime pie! So good that we ate two whole pies while there on vacation and ordered 4 more key lime pies, 1 chocolate peanut butter pie and 1 honeybell orange bunt cake to drive back to Canada with us. Great service and hospitality!

Margaret Meyers

We heard about this shop and had to try. I mistakenly read that it was open on New Year's Day, but was surprised when we found the door opened as the owner was taking down Christmas decorations. Although technically "closed", the owner graciously accommodated our purchase of two key lime pies--one for our family and one to share with three other friends so they could try it. We all unanimously agree that it was the absolute, BEST key lime pie we've ever had, and we've done 'exhaustive' research over the year! This shop is a definite MUST. We will be stopping back to try their other specialties, as this could be our new "Favorite" bakery in Sarasota.

Marcie Dos Santos

I was looking for a sympathy basket to ship to PA and Nancy helped me customize the perfect one! She was so helpful and thoughtful in her suggestions. Her shop is filled with so many fabulous Florida options, it was hard to choose. I went with a key lime theme and of course had to include some of her awesome cookies! My friend just received the basket and said it is the most beautiful and most unique gift basket she has ever received! Thank you Nancy, for helping me send some Florida love up north. I will definitely be back again to seek your help with sending other gifts!

Jaime gonzalez

Unforgettable key lime pie! Next time im stocking up my next visit to sarasota.

Cheryl Burch

We tried the key lime pie while we were visiting Siesta Key. We all agree that Floribbean Flo's key lime pie is the BEST key lime pie that we have ever eaten! We highly recommend this pie to anyone.

Jack Fahey

Flo's Key Lime Pie is the best I have ever had. I joked that one of the main reasons I moved to Sarasota Florida was to be closer the maker of the worlds best key lime pie..... but in reality... I wasn't kidding. It is truly one of a kind!!!

Tim Yales

They have the best key lime pie! Also tried some sandwiches at lunch: chicken, pulled pork, and ham. All were delicious, though the pork needed more BBQ sauce, though the sauce was delicious as well! We'll definitely be going back before our trip is over!!!

Richard Brown

Unique small shop along Tamiami Trail South of Siesta Key. Flavorful selection of cookies and nice key lime pie. Very personable owner and a very good place to small gift shop