Reviews of American Pie Company (Bakery)

29 Rte 37 Center, Sherman, CT 06784, United States

Average Rating:


You will be able to see the information of real people like you who are buying the services of American Pie Company (Bakery) near Connecticut.

At the moment the firm receives a score of 4.6 over 5 and the score was based on 490 reviews.

As you can see it has an average rating is practically the highest, and it is based on a large number of scores, so we may be quite sure that the evaluation is very accurate. If many people have bothered to evaluate when they are satisfied with the service, is that it works.

As you know, we don't usually stop to set reviews when they are correct and we usually do it only if we've had a problem or incidence...

This Bakery is included in the category of American restaurant.

Where is American Pie Company?

REVIEWS OF American Pie Company IN Connecticut

Frank N. Stein

I've been here with my family and friends on several occasions for breakfast and lunch never having a bad experience. The food and service has always been great. The pancakes with fresh fruit and whipped cream are delicious. My personal favorite is the bananas foster French toast which I highly recommend. For lunch I really enjoy the fish and chips which is cooked perfectly in a nice crunchy batter.


Found this the sweetest little country style place to eat with a friend called Britt. It was friendly, delightful and yummy.

Donna Ramirez

Excellent food. Hard to find location. Great bakery. Service was good. But very small dining area. Need to go early always line to be seated

Suzanne Dunham

You never leave hungry portions are great. Service waitress are great. Bakery is an added plus the place is just amazing.

David Granacher

Great service..excellent supper

Sean Griffin

Consistent food, cozy 80s country goose interior. Ingredient quality could be better. Doesn't support local farms, no pastured, or grass-fed meats, low quality eggs. Nothing too challenging, or exciting. Only game in town. Moderately priced. Very clean.


Great food and excellent service!

Thomas Sprague

Portions are unreal, I had plenty to take home. Desserts were outstanding

James Mc Cloy-Brooks

Yummy,Yummy in my tummy. Food is on point


They should get a Michelin star just for their homemade corned beef hash. All the other food is great to.

Loretta S

Cozy, home town feel...fantastic food! Great people, great service!

David DeJesus

Not worth the drive, even if I was local I wouldn't go here. Decent crust but fake tasting fillings.


Been coming here for years, mad fast service, workers are nice, and the food is gas

Susan Lucas

Oh the cupcakes! A special treat for grandkids; take them in and watch their eyes pop! Everything is so good there. Chicken Pot pie, any pie (peach/blueberry my favorite) donuts on Sunday morning. What a great place.

Dawn Jawrower

Great place for nostaglia

Gloria Nye

Great variety and service. Bakery attached and excellent

Scott Snow

Prompt service with a happy smile from our waitperson stood out even as much as the variety and quality of the menu selections we ordered. Portions were large so we had to box up and take home dessert from the bakery. We are good for may return trips to this small but homey little restaurant.

Michelle McCallion

The baked goods are the BEST

Reginald Perzon

Amazing, chicken salads, I like eating here early morning. They have good service and fresh food. I enjoy coming here because is so relaxing .

Antonio Omg

Omg most flavorful food I had in CT. The bakery cranks out some amazing deserts

Amy Moto

Outstanding breakfast/brunch

Farmer Brown

Expensive and not great. The food is decent, but not exceptional. However, the prices are pretty high for where they are. Plan to spend over $10 per person for breakfast and $15 to $20 for lunch. I would not complain except the food quality does not justify this price. The lemon filling for the lemon meringue pie tastes premade. Very sweet and not very lemony. This seems to be a trend with the desserts. Very sweet, but not very flavorful. The breakfasts are fine. They come with a generous portion of potatoes and decent toast. However they are not any better than breakfasts that are half as much. Same for the lunch and dinner entrees. The chicken pie is flavorful but does not contain much chicken. The burger is fine, as are the fries, but at $14 is not twice as good as a $7 Burger. Overall, a lot of money for an adequate but not good meal.

Linda Ercole

Had breakfast one morning and lunch a week later. Very good food and service. Next we will try dinner.

Michael T. Lieberman

Not only great pies & cookies but great food !!

Yolanda Carley

Best place in Sherman Conn. for breakfast, brunch/lunch, dinner. Friendly and attentive staff; great food, large selection of baked goods which are a bit pricey but sensational. Restaurant is small and cozy and it's a very popular spot for locals etc. so you may have to wait a while for a seat but it's well worth the wait.

Susan Fairchild

My first yesterday. The food was good and bought a cherry pie on the way out Yummy!

Donna Stevens-Jacobs

Fresh wholesome from scratch meals. I have never had a disappointing meal at American Pie.

Robert LeClerc

Been coming here since moving to the area and they are FANTASTIC! The food is great, always consistent and tastey! The menu is solid with an additional rotating seasonal menu that always delivers new and exciting items. The staff is very friendly and always on top of things! Top that with a chicken pot pie to die for and a great selection of bakery items and you have an awesome restaurant! Seriously the pot pie is FANTASTIC!

Robert Reilly

My Bill's Garbage Burger was delicious, with huge steak fries. My wife's Black and Bleu Burger was likewise yummy. Our friend's salad was HUGE and tastey. We talked for over 2 hours and never felt any pressure to hurry up.

Chris Ryan

I like this place. The food is always good. Sometimes the service can be a little slow but not horrible. When you make everything fresh and from scratch, it does take time. Worth a try!

Dana Noto

The best breakfast I think I've ever eaten! Had the blintzes with warm spiced apples. An experience for the taste buds not to be missed.

William thatenough

Had a late lunch around 2pm on a Saturday the place was busy had to wait 5 min for a table so no big deal. We were seated and had appetizers and cottage pie and chicken fried steak now obviously Shepard's pie is always a little bland but the chicken fried steak was also lacking any real spice. The table service was great especially for how busy it was and we were seated up stairs neither ate more than half of our meal even that we were hungry from skipping breakfast. Since the have the best pies we decided to get what they were known for and my wife wanted to take home a pot pie as it sounded good. We waited for 9 min with 4 people in red shirts behind the counter said excuse me to two of them and were ignored so she put the pot pie back and we decided we could find a different place to get the 2 pies we were looking to have this week. We doubt we will be coming back not sure how this place has such a high rating maybe the pies are that amazing we don't know we could not get served.

Anne Emerson

Terrific service and excellent food!


This place is a classic institution around these parts....their bakery is beacon for consistent quality...and their restaurant side doesn't disappoint in the least. With a wide variety of interesting selections the whole family will find something enjoyable at this cozy lil spot that house the feel of a country home. Save room for dessert!

Jason Burford

Large portions, good food. Very busy Sunday brunch

Evan Gold

I read this was rated the best breakfast place in Connecticut so, I had to see. The breakfast was very very good. I would go back but, I would not drive the 1hr. To get there. We like to explore and certainly was not disappointed. Oh the cupcakes were off the hook. If you go there get them!!!!

Robert Dorrian

Food was great and service was too

Juliana Correa

Good food, staff very friendly!

Mike Montavo

Awesome!! Love love this place. Food is delicious! Real comfort food and the pies are great. Staff is excellent..can't say enough. If you're nearby make a point to stop on in.

Enmartz Anderson

My lady took me there for my birthday. We were both very surprised to see the vast array of delicious deserts. BTW, thier keylime pie was excellent, great crust and taste. We had the samplers breakfast and it was very good. I really enjoyed the pancake. The staff was very friendly and attentive. Prices were good too. I'm looking forward to my next visit, and so sure you!!!!!

donna salazar

AMAZING food!! It’s a treat to eat here as often as I can..if I lived nearby I would never cook

Jhonnattan F

Friendly staff. Our waitress was funny and great service. I must say that food was amazing big portions and tasty. Will be returning again.

J Lord

Food was excellant

Stan Greenbaum

Good food, good value. Tasty pies!

barry kenny

Food and service have always been excellent. We have gone for breakfast, lunch and dinner and have not had a bad experience

Donna Pepe

Amazing food and a great place to eat.

Jeffrey Gibson

Great pies, great country cooking for hearty meals. Brunch is excellent. Can be crowded, and not ideal for waits given there is no real bar portion. Beer and wine only btw!

John Muniz

Great foood and desserts

Rommie Duckworth

American Pie has GREAT breakfasts and baked good. It can get crowded on nice weekends, especially int he morning, but the food and service is always good. Their dinners are good as well. Don't expect anything spicy (unless specified on the menu) but you'll get great home-cooked food.

Hilary Czerniawski

I really liked this restaurant and definately want to go back for brunch. I had the sampler breakfast today but the french toast was dry. Efficient staff, pleasant atmosphere. I wish they had real maple syrup.

Frank Seipp

Lovely staff and delicious food

Rosie C

I don't go there much. But always disappointed with desserts. Not enough flavor/ sweetness in Danish, cookies, needs a little more sugar spices. Food is just ok. Same problem. Maybe it's me?

Leo Jette

Great food and service

Marlane White

If you don't want to stop for scrumptious comfort cafe food, at least pick up one of their frozen chicken pot pies to cook at home for the entire family.

Diane Thomsen

Nice evening with close friends and daughter. Good selection of comfort food.

donna morales

Love this place, just an old fashion diner.

Paul S

Great breakfast and pies

Kevin Schick

Great throwback vibe and amazing food!

Catherine Kelly

I love this place. It is a wonder, living as close to it as I do, that I don't weigh 500 lbs. Try their chicken pot pie sometime...definite comfort food.


Great food, great service, free refills on coffee - what more can you ask for? The menu has a wide variety of options including the amazing breakfast fajita and even a low carb option for those of us trying to watch our waistlines (or making a token effort to do so, haha).

Paul Lourd

Great local place A Sherman tradition. Lots of variety on the menu and good specials. Plus of course the bakery for pies and stuff. Food seem to be of good quality. Never had a bad meal here.

Scott Whitman

If you find yourself in Sherman CT stop for breakfast or lunch. Chicken pot pie is top notch but you can't miss with most of the menu. Also highly recommend California melt. Casual bakery with sit down service.

A Monshaw

Amazing bakery/restaurant. Love to go here for dinner almost as much as breakfast, but if you're going for breakfast expect to wait a couple minutes. 100% worth the wait every time. Highly recommend the peanut butter cookies, Boston creme pie and any of the burgers/steak sandwiches. Amazing omelettes, pastries and home fries for breakfast.

Vladimir Pade

Hot meals, sandwiches and pies. Outstanding selection

Tom Brown

A Sherman tradition of excellence. I would describe American Pie as a combination of diner and artisinal bakery. They have an excellent menu selection, and their bakery offers great bread and cake choices. The cookies are enormous and delicious. The wait staff is very friendly and accommodating. I highly recommend eating here.

Frances McCoy

We always make American Pie company the first stop for any day date day. We love this place!!!! The best breakfast place!

Judith Wagner

Although the place is a little small for comfort sitting, it's a clean place, food orders come out very quickly and always tasteful. I need to try more plates because I order your roast beef plate . Too good to miss it. Number 1 favorite.

Jessica Mongeau

The staff were lovely and extremely helpful. Food was delicious! Even my picky toddler loved her kids meal. Definitely will stop by again the next time I am out this way.

Nancy Maurice

Great local spot with good comfort food. Outdoor dining in season with lovely flowers. Also a bakery-homemade dog cookies

liz almeida

Favorite place for a home cooked meal! It always smells amazing there. I always make room for dessert not matter how full I am. And always get a frozen homemade chicken pot pie to bake at home on the way out!

Barbara Ferris

Everything is good at American Pie. Great hometown restaurant. Everyone is so nice. I buy my Thanksgiving pies there every year. Some of my favorites....I Love their Bananas Foster French toast. Chicken Pot Pie and they have the best Apple Cider donuts around!!! Trust! Yum!

D. Anthony P

This is a must stop if you have never been and it's definitely a place for repeat meals and deserts. The food is amazing and the staff and service is exceptional. American Pie is one of my favorite places.

Drake Strong

Great food but pricey

Raymond Kb2nzo78

Great place for dinner and a terrific pic

Jasmine Barker

Stopped here for lunch on the way to White Silo Winery! The portions are huge and the service was amazing! Highly recommend this place. They have a bakery inside as well as a full menu to sit and have breakfast or lunch.

Patrick C. O'Connell

Food was amazinnnnnnnnnnnnnngggggggg, it blew me away

Amber M

Have gone to American Pie company for years; it never disappoints. The chefs are amazing, giving just as much attention to detail to a bacon, egg, and cheese as they do eggs Benedict; which they have many delicious variations on. I myself got the limited time "Munich Eggs Benedict" special today; poached eggs with hollandaise, bratwurst, and potato pancakes; and it was amazing. Add on top of this the wide variety of the menu and the fact that they bake their own bread/pastries fresh everyday and I can't imagine there's a better diner within the state of Connecticut, maybe in all of New England. Staff is always kind and attentive, and the food comes out really fast as long as they aren't swamped. That's the one down side of this place; it's so good that it can take a long time to get a seat on a Weekend morning some days; but I have never regretted going when it's busy, they are always worth the wait.

Michelle Lorenzen

Great food and bakery. Homestyle cooking and friendly service!

Peter Bielawa

Great food every time we go.

Paul Gouveia

American Pie is absolutely excellent. A local staple. The food is always fresh and homey, it will remind you of a relatives home cooked meals. The selection is good and rotates with the seasons. The pies and desserts are on an entirely different level! Nobody beats their pies anywhere I've ever been, stop in and enjoy!

Kerri Bauer

This was the best breakfast ! Service was friendly and quick! We will definitely be coming back!!

Edward Durden

Key Lime Pie is great. It's about 20 dollars but worth it for special treat. It is not dyed bright green with food coloring. Real deal. Fresh,sweet, and not too heavy.

Veronica Hopkins

The portion size for dinner can feed a whole family. I had macaroni and cheese...could have been spicier but delicious all the same. The waitress was very pleasant,as well as efficient. We even were checked on by the the owner. We laughed, we ate, we had a great time. Totally recommend.

Jason Ojeda

Hands down my favorite local restaurant. The environment is great and the food is amazing. My suggestion is to go off meal hours because it is small and fills up quickly. You cannot go wrong with any dish here!

carole cipkas

We stopped on the way back home from Stormville Airport Flea Market and were pleasantly surprised. The food was absolutely delicious and the portions quite large for the price. We took a Strawberry Rhubarb pie home and needless to say, was just as good! Well be back!

Louis C

Excellent comfort food such as Pot Roast and Chicken Pot Pie. Home made taste. Great service. Don't miss the desserts. Large selection of pie flavors.

Leo Luning

The pie was excellent; however, the location is out of the way of pretty much all of society.

Rebecca Nguyen

Family favorite. Have been dozens of times. Great American food, especially brunch. There is often a wait, but it is totally worth it. Staff is excellent.

Savannah L. Hastey

Never a bad meal, and your pies can always turn a bad day around. Brought my boyfriend here for his first time this morning and he can't wait to come back!

Karen Preissler

Very good foods, a little hard for me to make a choice from so many tempting offerings. Chili, soup, salads, main courses, sandwiches, wraps, burgers, blintzes. They'll serve you from breakfast menu almost all day. (To about 4PM by request.) Friendly, smooth and fast service. Good coffee. Haven't had all their different pies yet and their idea of layering warm pie of your choice with ice cream sounds so very delicious. There's pastries, cakes and whole pies for sale too. Right next door to Sherman post office.

Sandra Calvin

Great Food

Charles Kline

Love their pot pie !!

Elizabeth Czelowalnik

Great food!!!! Great service. Its a busy place so go hungry and w some patience


First time I've ever been here and it was amazing. The food was perfect staff was friendly I look forward two going back again on my next visit up north.

david tice

Great comfort food classics and huge portions make this a favorite place to go.

Ann Marie Tozzi

My family and I are frequent customers here. Large choice of dishes including a children's menu. Deserts are outstanding!

Paul Bartomioli

Old school bakery. Great choices.

Tama Murphy

The staff here is super nice and friendly. I always stop here when I'm in Sherman. I have yet to have a bad meal! And, there are always leftovers!

Samantha Cairl

First time going there and l immediately fell in love! Is small and cozy. Great food especially their pies! Definitely a great place to go to meet up with friends.

Allison Bauman

Everything is awesome. I've never had anything that wasn't great. If I had to narrow it down, I'd recommend the French onion soup, the potato pancakes, the nachos or a breakfast omelet. But again, you can't go wrong here. The staff is so nice and the owner is literally always there. They also have great desserts. Can't say enough good things about this place. There is usually a wait but it's never very long and it is so worth it.

Timothy Smith

Good home cooked feeling. Had the buffalo chicken salad and cottage pie. The staff are friendly. The prices for the baked goods are a bit high, but the food is very reasonable.

Pat Sharik

We always enjoy having breakfast at here whenever we are in the area.

Shari Gleissner

I love American Pie. Food and bakery items are always fresh and taste delicious. You can eat in the restaurant or pick up items. I don't know if they have home deliveries. Cakes, pies and other items can be made to order, such as birthday cakes and other events.

Allen Powell

Great spot for breakfast. Highly recommended.

Nick C.

Amazing peach raspberry pie!

Patricia DelVecchio

Favorite breakfast spot.

lorie gonzalez

AMAZING! One of the BEST places I have ever eaten at.

Carole Lynn

Stopped by 3 weeks ago Saturday. Picked up a crumb cake and raspberry peach pie slice. Counter service gal and guy most unfriendly. No hello and very short answers when i asked about the pies. First visit and decided to take out instead of sit down due to the unwelcoming staff. BUT the crumb cake was melt in your mouth delicious. As fresh as could possibly be. The pie slice was just as special. The crust was light and the filling perfectly sweet. I have baked at home most of my life and the cake and pie were excellent. But too bad the staff didn't hold up to the quality of the baked goods.

Glen Sauer

Love the people and food fair prices

Nancy Klarman

A favorite of mine for many years.

Daniel Fox

Hate the place


Best breakfast place in the area. Quality service and food. I love American pie

Ken Bennett

Great food and friendly staff.

Anthony Zagarella

Awesome food ,good size portion like mom maid

Gregory Weiss

Very good breakfast and lunch. Omelettes are large and delicious. Creative specials, especially holiday/seasonal stuff. Gets very busy at lunch time, but late morning and afternoon are typically quieter. Always good service. Beer selection isn't terrible. Bakery is outstanding.

Nadia Therese

Excellent diner. Food is divine! You have to try the chicken pot pie.

William Chuisano

Always a great meal with friendly staff. But the deserts... YUMMM!!

Bernard Paquette

Picked up some Desserts for the weekend, They have awsome Eclairs, cookies, cupcakes & muffins and Don't for get the pies.

Michael A. Rodriguez

Love the food. Desserts are good too. Can be crowded on weekends. Reasonably priced. Staff always willing to accommodate. Upstairs seating is really nice for larger parties.

Alan A

Good, basic, family style food. Mains are $15 and up and include soup or salad. The chicken pot pie is excellent and so is the turkey dinner. If you like salads as a main course try the shrimp with garlic or the cranzinger salad. And since their name is American Pie, you have to have a piece of pie for desert.

Joann Slattery

Awesome food and great staff

Diane Murphy

Awesome food and amazing pies!

Susan Funk

The Pie is a great place to grab a bite to eat. Whether you are having anything from a salad to a full dinner with a piece of pie. The cowboy chili is one of my favorites along with a chocolate swirl shortbread cookie.

Mary Carchidi

Food and service are great. There aren't many places to eat out in Sherman, so thankfully the food is good. They have great early bird specials.

Eric Schofield

Great chicken pot pie! The dessert pies look pretty awesome too so I'm going to have to go back and do some sampling


Good coffee, good food and better service. I can't wait to eat our pie!

Greg Wolf

On Father's Day the bacon was fatty and under cooked. The Potato Pile Up was also under cooked. They were busy, but food should only be served when it's Ready to be served. It should Not be served because of busy-ness in the restaurant. However, my dish was good.

Michael Reynolds

Amazing food and amazing pies. They serve their breakfast menu until 4p.

Rey Fortea

Feels like the best bits of old Americana. Amazing food, delicious bakery treats, and fantastic service.

Joseph Irizarry

Stopped in after a ride in the area. Wonderful selection of pies, desserts, frozen pot pies. Sat down to enjoy a delicious Reuben sandwich with potato salad. Return trip imminent...

Frank Saccente

Nice people food is great bathroom always clean

The Green Baron

Food is excellent!

leaf corcoran

Much food.. good price. got huge omelette

Russell Salazar

Fantastic food, great baked goods and pies to take home after!

OkDude DudeOk

Im there every Friday for breakfast

krad dark

Great food the employees are very friendly. Prices are good for the portions you get the one downside is it's a very small place so if it's crowded you might have to wait a little while

Richard Bross

On beatable breakfast special. Eggs, bacon,home fries, toast & coffee. All done just right for $6.99 + tax Plus great service !!

Dianne Hansen

Great food, they know pies, take a chicken pot pie home. Strawberry rhubarb pie is intense, few places know how to do them right. Order what you like and enjoy, leave your calorie counter at home.

Chris Coladarci

Great meals and pies and desserts. Pot roast is great. Strawberry rhubarb pie is the best.

Margaret Wilbert

The food is great. Service is spot on. And breakfast is filling and great. I love this place!

Tim Dubya

Very good food. Make sure to get one of the pies they are great.

Esteve DV

Great people and great food. Huge portions and worth the wait. Great chicken pot pie, omelettes, banana foster french toast, turkey dinner, and pies!

irene dailey

The food was delicious. The staff was outrageously polite and accommodating. As a party of 6 we called ahead to make a reservation as we were traveling from Terryville , an hours trip. I was told our name was put down and to come on over. When we got there I went up to counter to tell them we were there, and mistakenly said I had a reservation, did not know they didnt take reservations, but they took call aheads. Which was okay, but it was said to me a very sharp manner, not by a staff member, but the owner I later found out. Okay it didnt sit well, but I decided to let it slide, it was busy. But not 15 minutes later when we were seated, he passed our table and again snapped for me to move my purse as he felt it would trip someone. And indeed it may have, but again it was the tone. I said something to our waitress and she said not to take it personal. Actually I kinda did, but it was a busy Sunday aftetnoon. But a little later he came by our table to make sure everything and one was doing okay. But all in all, the food, the staff ,and atmosphere was wonderful. Thanks For a good meal. I.M.S. And yes we will go back, the food is too good not to.!

Marc Williams

Awesome place for breakfast...lunch....or dinner. Great country atmosphere. Awesome food great value! Breakfast amazing!

beckie bou

Awesome food worth the drive!!

Matt Werner

The food here is always good and you can tell it is all homemade. Great spot for an easy lunch or great breakfast after a long night

Sandy Servidio

Excellent omelette, very friendly service. Loved! My friend had french toast with custard, strawberries and whip creme OMG, AMAZING!

Christopher Olivera

Best breakfast around. Except to wait. The later you go the longer the wait. Well worth it.

Business Hours of American Pie Company in Connecticut



American Pie Company en Connecticut
View Phone Number
View WebPage

Others also saw
Hen & Heifer
Hen & Heifer
Bakery - Connecticut


Giuseppina's Italian Bakery
Giuseppina's Italian Bakery
Bakery - Connecticut


SoDelicious HomeMade Bakery
SoDelicious HomeMade Bakery
Bakery - Connecticut


Gutiz Restaurant and Bakery
Gutiz Restaurant and Bakery
Bakery - Connecticut


Love Heart's Bakery
Love Heart's Bakery
Bakery - Connecticut