Reviews of Alexander Baking Co. (Bakery)

Alicia Nicholson

We came in here Saturday & the customer service was awesome! So sweet and welcoming! The sugar cookies looked amazing and tasted delicious. We got a couple of cupcakes that were delicious as well. The store is super cute, perfect spot for the little bakery!

Kim Miles

My family and friends love everything that Alexander Baking Co. has on their menu. We have ordered a few hundred cookies from Brooke and have never been disappointed. She is very talented and professional. I enjoyed my cookies and cream birthday cake just a few days ago tremendously! Can't wait for the sausage rolls on Saturday morning!! Merry Christmas and best wishes to the staff.

Christina Helt

I purchased a dozen Christmas cookies for my daughters elf to bring her. She LOVED them!! They were so soft & moist and delicious!!! We will definitely be stopping by frequently. Brooke waited on me and was so helpful and sweet!

Robby Burchit

Great cookies. Great service. Great times. White chocolate cranberry cookies are the best. Seriously the best bakery in town.

Rick McLeod

We've worked with Brooke on several orders, both cookies and cupcakes, and they are always perfect! Alexander Baking Co is our "go-to!"

Hot Tomato

Love it!!

xi huynh

Cute place to just stop by and get some cookies. My favorite cookie is the peanut butter cookie. Simple and savory.

Lauren Miles

The white chocolate cranberry cookies here are to die for!

Sheila Alexander

Everything here is awesome, from the decorated cookies to cupcakes and cakes and macarons!! Such a talent this girl has!!

Brian Adams

A really close friend who lives out of town wanted to surprise me for my birthday with a customized birthday cake. I did not know this until the day of my birthday, and I was given a location where to pick it up. I had never heard of this bakery, but I can tell you that I'm going to tell everybody that I know about it. My birthday cake was incredible, the flavor was sublime and unforgettable. It was my dream cake come to life. No more traveling to Fayetteville for me; I will be coming here in the future!

Linda Bell

Very artistic and creative, plus delicious!!!!

Sarah Sears

Amazing experience! The treats are delicious, and the decorating is breathtaking. Be sure to take a peek at the decorating in person! Even my grandma says it’s the best sugar cookie she’s ever had!

Justin Wood

Food was great

Jordyn Sexson

Best cookies around. Brooke shipped to Kansas for a birthday and they were beautiful.....love her creativity

Rebecca Collins

Alexander Baking Co is awesome! I loved the Midtown Cookies that Brooke made especially for our office!! Perfection!

Chelsea Thomas

I have LOVED everything I have ever purchased from this adorable bakery! We had my daughters bday party here and Brooke absolutely killed it!! She was so kind and patient with the young kids! We will continue coming back!

Brandi Hamilton

Wow! Love Alexander Baking Company! The cookies are fantastic - great taste and amazing design!

sheila hellerich

Wonderful baked goods. I always stop in to get a couple of chocolate chip cookies. Remind me of the one my mom used to bake. Top notch.

Josh Miller

Stopped by to have some papers signed and on my way out I bought a cupcake and cook. They were both really good and my wife and little boy enjoyed them! Thanks Brooke, you have a great place! I like locally owned operations like this!

Morgan Oakes

Alexander Baking Co. made our wedding cake for our September wedding. I could not have been happier with the overall experience and final product. I do not live in Rogers, but Brooke went out of her way to accommodate my schedule and needs for a tasting. She was extremely easy to work with and went above and beyond to transport my cake and set it up. Her prices are really reasonable and I had a lot of people telling me how great the cake was! It turned out even better than I imagined it would! I highly recommend Alexander Baking Co.!

Keith Edgeworth

Awesome baked goods and customer service!

Jennifer Jensen

Wonderful bakery with all sorts of goodies!

anastasia sholar

Very friendly, well priced and the cutest corner if the downtown strip in Rogers

Carly Andersen

Amazing service and product. I've already ordered 5 dozen cookies and there will absolutely be more orders in my future!

Ademote Thumbutu

Beautiful Designs, Amazing Quality and Absolutely Delicious! Brooke was Very responsive when I ordered and my order came out exactly how I wanted it. I will definitely be purchasing from her again!

Ava• Claire

OMG ITS SOOO GOOD I REALLY RECCOMEND IT. SO PROUD OF YOU.

Emily Blumhardt

Unwelcoming (snobby/indifferent) customer service, limited selection, expensive. $1.25 for a small cookie, $4 for a decorated sugar cookie with very few to choose from. More of a special order place, so it seems odd to have a storefront, especially with poor customer service.

Madelynne P

It was lit.

Anne Morrow

We visited from Pittsburgh, PA recently. The selection was limited but the items we bought were super fresh and the service was fast and friendly. The chocolate chip cookies were soft and delicious and my fiance and I agreed that the peanut butter cookies were the best peanut butter cookies we have ever had! (And we visit bakeries everywhere we travel). We wanted to go back and buy more to take home but the shop was closed on Sunday. The custom cake in the case looked very professional. -Someone here has a lot of talent. I hope the locals keep it open so I can get more next time I visit!