Reviews of A Pie Stop (Bakery)

Autumn Beatty

The pie is out of this world! The service, however, is terrible! I don’t appreciate being treated like an imposition! Will probably not come here again because of the way we were treated.

Nicole Emanuel

My family came in on a Saturday and was utterly impressed by the delicious pies and friendly service! We were warmly welcomed by Christian, a kind and outgoing server. We shared a seafood pot pie, which was enchanting. I'd never had a pot pie with seafood rather than meat - this one made me an instant fan! Crab, shrimp, and salmon nestled with creamy rice and peas, all in one of the best buttery, flaky crusts I've had in a while. A savory sensation! We had to get a mini dessert pie to take home, and settled on triple berry. Even the excellence of our lunch didn't fully prepare me for the delight of what I would experience: this heavenly baked good blew me away. Berry pie is one of my all time favorite foods on earth, and I've had some dang good slices in my day. A Pie Stop's ranks right up there with the best of 'em. I'm already dreaming about coming back!

Dennis Young

Anchorage! This is great pie! Don't miss it!!!❤️

Michelle Mitton

Best pie I've had in Anchorage! (Though Simon and Seaforts has a killer key lime). Bought a triple berry pie and it's the first time I've enjoyed the crust as much as the filing. Yes, they're expensive unless you consider that it's a dessert for 6-8 people. The shop itself isn't fancy but clean and service was quick. I plan on trying some of their other flavors.

Sarah Burtner

The peach pie was absolutely gorgeous and had the best filling I've ever tasted! Unfortunately, our family was very disappointed in the gluten-free crust. It was bland, tough, and nothing like the tender, crusty ones I make at home with butter and a GF flour blend. We live very close by and would love to patronize your shop regularly. Let us know if you offer other GF options!

Sivaboon Wissanee

We stop at Korean restaurants and my husband want to have a piece of Coconut cream pie but the small one. They didn't have one on shelf, so we got the fresh one in 10 mins!!! I just think they are so nice to doing that for us.

Vygintas Kunigenas

Double the price for the supermarket quality pie. Tried both on the same day. There are just too many better options in town, most of them in safer neighborhoods and better run.

Christy Runestad

The Lemon meringue pie, Apple Pie and Beef Pasties are so delicious!

Nikoal

Try the whoopie pie you won't be disappointed.

yomara rivera-saunders

Love their savory pies. Reminds me of my childhood....

Robyn Syren

My husband picked up an apple pie for me as a surprise. It is my favorite pie. I was a little disappointed in my pie, the bottom crust wasn't baked and the apples were still very crunchy, almost like eating raw apples. I am not sure I would buy another pie.

Grant Hartwig

Great pies. They are pricey but you get what you pay for. I would definitely buy this for a gift or to bring to a party. $27 a pie is steep for me but the pies are worth it.

Ashley Godbold

Amazing sweet and savory pies!

Cecil Lloyd Brown

"I'm here for the pie." I ate in. It was good. I wish it was served on a dish instead of a Styrofoam bowl. But seriously? Homey slices of pie and hot drinks from a drive through window? Yeah, I'll be back.

Allison Wheatley

Yummy pies! Savory and sweet. Get there early to get your favorite, or come later and discover a new one. If you really love pie, ask Steve for their Signature special. You won't be disappointed.

Jennifer Alger

Had a strawberry pie from there... it was delicious! Way better than Fred Meyers or Carrs. Their crusts is amazing.

Lee Jones

I love rhubarb pie and this is as good as my grandmother's...never thought I would say that about any pie, let alone rhubarb.

Ken Schumacher

Excellent pie and the pasties are good too !

Oana G

This place looked like a small shop from the outside... but inside it's a cozy, inviting place, with comfortable seats and yellow walls- very warm and inviting! I had the strawberry rhubarb pie, the perfect combination of sweet and tangy! Highly recommended!

Melissa Moody

I was just given the triple berry pie as a thank you gift... I haven't been to the store in person, but OH MAN is this pie just delicious. Like... super, super tasty.

Char Wilcoxon

Never ever been told I couldn't purchase a slice of pie before. Cheapest pie $11.00 for the smallest pie. Very pricey!

Janet Elson

I'm loving the Pastys! Always nice an hot and ready to eat!

Rachel Forrer

Great little place! Delicious, fresh, beautiful pies. Definitely recommend!

brandon coyle

My Fiancee and I have been trying to come in for a while now and were pleasantly surprised at the clean neat appearance and the wide selection of deserts. The prices were incredible and the food was amazing. Five stars for sure!!!

Susan Sharpless

I called from Batesville Indiana and with in minutes I connected with Dawn. I wasn't looking to order pies but within minutes of our conversation I knew the Pie Company would fit my request. My youngest son birthday was March 11th. Because he can't come home like years past for his birthday I was calling different bakiers to find someone that would be willing to take my precious son something for his birthday. Without hesitation Dawn was that person. She went above and beyond and delivered 2 beautiful apple pies my son veery favorite, with a ballon that said happy birthday and sent me pictures. I am so pleased and grateful for what she did for me and my son. Not only will I call again when I come to Alaska this summer to visit; I am coming to buy pies and meet wonderful Dawn. Also, my boy said he wasn't sharing his pies and was taking them home. He loved the pies and I am sure they will be visiting the Pie Company. One happy mama all the way all the way from Indiana. Thank You and God Bless You Dawn

Kristine Asuncion

We are totally in love with their Coconut Cream pies & Bavarian Pear Pie!

Pitlac Powderhound

Under new ownership, not honoring gift cards. When I indicated I was not interested in purchasing from the Pie Stop new owner threw the card at me thru the drive up window. Although Historically love their pie's would suggest avoiding...

Corrina Chang

Best key lime pie!! The crust is crisp and delicious. I am not from Anchorage and from a big city. This pie shop is unique and has a good energy. I came here twice while I was in town bc the pies are tasty. I love supporting small businesses bc they help the community thrive!! Love love love and I highly highly recommend!!!!

Robert Croft

After the earthquake the owner was great he let us stay there until out flight.....pies WOW!!!!